Title of Invention

ANTIFOULING MATERIAL AND PRODUCTION METHOD THEREOF

Abstract The invention relates to a material comprising a substrate which is provided with a titanium oxide-based coating which is topped with a thin hydrophilic layer. The aforementioned thin hydrophilic layer forms at least part of the external surface of the material and does not comprise titanium oxide. The invention relates to the use of said material in order to prevent mineral fouling from being deposited on the external surface in the absence of water runoff.
Full Text ANTIFOULING MATERIAL AND PRODUCTION METHOD THEREOF
The present invention relates to the field of
materials, in particular glazing panels, which are
antisoiling or self cleaning.
Titanium oxide is known for having photocatalytic
properties. In the presence of light, and especially
ultraviolet radiation of UV-A type (of which the
wavelength is between 320 and 400 nm) , titanium oxide
has the particular feature of catalyzing the radical
degradation reactions of organic compounds. It is known
from documents EP-A-850 204 and EP-A-816 466 that
- titanium oxide also has extremely pronounced
hydrophilic properties induced by the same type of
radiation. This hydrophilicity, sometimes referred to
as "super-hydrophilicity" is characterized by a very
small water contact angle, of less than 5°, or even
less than 1°. These two properties, photocatalysis on
the one hand and super-hydrophilicity on the other
hand, give the material containing titanium oxide
particularly advantageous properties. Materials, in
particular of the ceramic, glass or glass-ceramic type,
coated with a thin layer of titanium oxide have, in
effect, antisoiling or self cleaning or else ease-of-
cleaning properties. A glazing panel covered with a
photocatalytic titanium oxide layer degrades the
organic soiling which is deposited thereon under the
action of sunlight. Mineral soiling is itself partly
prevented from being deposited and partly removed owing
to the photoinduced super-hydrophilicity of the
titanium oxide. Mineral soiling, in certain cases, is
in effect caused to be deposited on glazing panels in a
form dissolved in raindrops, and precipitates during
the evaporation of said drops. Owing to the super-
hydrophilicity properties, the water coats and cleans
the glazing instead of being deposited thereon in the
form of drops, which therefore prevents the deposition

of mineral soiling by this mechanism of
deposition/evaporation of water drops. As for mineral
soiling such as dust which is deposited without the aid
of rain, for example under the action of wind, it is
quite simply removed by rainwater runoff. The materials
obtained therefore allow the removal of organic and
mineral soiling under the combined effect of solar
radiation and water, in particular rain, runoff.
The materials described previously have, however, a
drawback when they are placed in a site protected from
the rain or in a geographical zone that very rarely
experiences precipitation. Specifically, it has been
observed that, placed in an atmosphere rich in mineral
soiling and sheltered from the rain, glazing panels
covered with photocatalytic titanium oxide and that are
super-hydrophilic are gradually covered with mineral
soiling, in particular in the form of very adherent
dust. After long-term exposure, especially for more
than 2 months, or even 4 months, such glazing has a
surface that is as dirty as that of a glazing panel
devoid of a titanium oxide layer. In the absence of
water runoff, the super-hydrophilic titanium oxide
surface does not therefore prevent the deposition and
adhesion of mineral soiling.
One object of the invention is therefore to overcome
these drawbacks by providing a material that prevents
the deposition of mineral soiling on its surface,
therefore that has little dust accumulation, including
in the absence of water runoff. Another object of the
invention is to provide a material capable of not being
soiled after several months of exposure in sites that
are protected from the rain or geographical zones that
very rarely experience precipitation.
The inventors have discovered that the substrates
covered with a titanium oxide layer, itself surmounted

by a thin layer of another hydrophilic material, in
particular of the type comprising silicon and oxygen,
had, completely unexpectedly, the technical effect
consisting in preventing the deposition of mineral
soiling (therefore dust accumulation) on its surface in
the absence of water runoff.
Some of these materials are known and described in
several documents. Application WO 2005/040056
describes, for example, a glazing panel covered with a
titanium oxide layer surmounted by a thin layer of
aluminum-doped silica having a coating capacity and a
thickness of 2 nm. The two layers are deposited by a
sputtering process then annealed together in order to
confer a high photocatalytic activity to the titanium
oxide. The upper silica layer has the effect of
improving the mechanical strength, in particular the
abrasion resistance, of the multilayer. Patent
US 6 379 776 also describes a multilayer on glass
comprising, in particular, a photocatalytic titanium
oxide layer, placed on which is a single layer of SiOx,
x being equal to 1 or 2. The latter layer is described
as having the effect of preventing the deposition of
organic soiling on the surface of the stack, but a
possible effect on the deposition of mineral soiling in
the absence of water runoff is not disclosed. This
patent moreover describes tests carried out outside
that demonstrate an absence of soiling deposition after
six months of exposure, it being specified that the
surface of the samples was subjected to rainwater
runoff. Application EP-A-1 074 525 itself describes a
structure of the same type, having on its outer surface
a thin layer of SiO2 of 10 nm or less, that makes it
possible to improve the hydrophilicity of the material
without too substantially degrading the performance in
terms of photocatalysis. No effect of this overlayer
relative to the deposition of mineral soiling in the
absence of water runoff is described.

The technical effect presented by this type of material
and which has very recently been discovered, consisting
in preventing the deposition of mineral soiling on its
surface in the absence of water runoff, has therefore
never been entertained. It is also surprising as it can
in no way be connected to the properties already
described in the prior art. The low adhesion of organic
soiling is, in effect, a property of low chemical
affinity with organic compounds, linked to the
hydrophilic nature of the layer and not correlated to
the adhesion of mineral soiling. However, the
hydrophilic nature alone of a surface does not prevent
the adhesion of mineral soiling in the absence of water
runoff, as the case of titanium oxide demonstrates.
One subject of the invention is therefore the use of a
material composed of a substrate equipped with a
coating based on titanium oxide surmounted by a thin
hydrophilic layer forming at least one part of the
outer surface of said material and that is not composed
of titanium oxide, as a material that prevents the
deposition of mineral soiling on said outer surface in
the absence of water runoff.
The expression "outer surface" should be understood,
within the meaning of the present invention, to be a
surface in contact with the ambient air, the only
surface capable of being soiled.
Without wishing to be tied to any one scientific
theory, it seems that the materials used according to
the invention, owing to their structural
characteristics, do not accumulate dust (or only
accumulate a little dust) owing to a mechanism of
reducing the friction coefficient between the surface
of the material and the mineral soiling, leading to a
much easier removal of this soiling, or even to actual

antiadhesive properties. This property of little dust
accumulation is in any case completely independent of
the known properties of photocatalysis and photoinduced
hydrophilicity, as the remainder of the description
will demonstrate.
Thin hydrophilic layer
The thin hydrophilic layer acts in synergy with the
titanium oxide, since none of these layers alone
produces the technical effect discovered.
In order that this synergistic effect occurs
effectively at the surface of the material, the thin
hydrophilic layer must preferably have small
thicknesses, thicknesses of less than 10 nm, or even
5 nm and in particular of 1 to 2 nm being preferred.
This synergistic effect is maximized and the best
performances are obtained when the thin hydrophilic
layers are capable of creating, in the presence of
ambient moisture and owing to the underlying presence
of the titanium oxide, a hydration layer that is not
very dense, in particular that is less dense than
liquid water, this hydration layer being, in addition,
particularly durable, even in the absence of
illumination. This particular hydration layer could
then have the effect of considerably reducing the
friction coefficient between the surface of the thin
hydrophilic layer and the mineral soiling. The latter
would thus slide much more easily over the outer
surface of the material instead of being deposited
thereon and adhering thereto. This preferred
characteristic is not found in the materials described
previously, the materials having this characteristic
are also one subject of the present invention.
The thin hydrophilic layer should not be composed of

titanium oxide. It may contain some, advantageously in
an amount less than 20 mol%, or even 10 mol%. According
to one preferred embodiment and in order to obtain very
little dust accumulation, it is however free or almost
free of titanium oxide.
Another characteristic of the thin hydrophilic layers
used according to the invention lies in the high
density of hydroxyl (OH) groups at their surface. It
appears that the higher this density is, the more
pronounced is the technical effect discovered within
this scope of the present invention.
Thus, preferred thin hydrophilic layers are based on
silicon and oxygen and especially comprise silica
(SiO2) , in particular doped with atoms such as aluminum
(Al) or zirconium (Zr), the latter increasing the
density of surface hydroxyl groups. Doping rates
ranging from 3 to 15 at% and preferably from 5 to
10 at% are particularly advantageous.
Other thin hydrophilic layers based on silicon and
oxygen, such as SiOC, SiON or SiOx, with x be used according to the invention, but are not
preferred as the number of hydroxyl groups generated at
the surface is lower than in the case of silica (SiO2) .
It is the same for layers comprising silicon and oxygen
such as silicates of alkali or alkaline-earth metal
ions. Thin hydrophilic layers based on alumina (Al2O3)
are also possible.
In order to obtain the lowest possible dust
accumulation, the thin hydrophilic layers, especially
based on optionally doped silica, are preferably not
annealed, that is to say are not subjected to a heat
treatment at more than 500°C, or even 200°C, the effect
of the heat treatment being precisely to decrease the
density of hydroxyl groups at the surface of the layer.

In this context, the thin hydrophilic layers are
preferably obtained by a process chosen from
sputtering, the sol-gel process and the plasma-enhanced
chemical vapor deposition process (PECVD, or APPECVD
when it is carried out at atmospheric pressure) , these
processes being carried out at low temperature.
The annealed thin hydrophilic layers also have little
dust accumulation, which seems however to be greater
than in the case of the non-annealed layers. This is
the case, for example, for the layers obtained by
chemical vapor deposition (CVD), this process being
generally carried out on a hot substrate, between 500
and 700°C.
The thin hydrophilic layers may be covering
(continuous) and form in this case the whole of the
outer surface of the material. They may alternatively
not be completely covering, a discontinuous layer, for
example in the form of islands that are separated or
joined together, that make it possible to obtain a
particularly high photocatalytic activity. In this
case, the outer surface of the material comprises the
underlying titanium oxide in the parts not covered by
the hydrophilic layer.
According to certain embodiments, the thin hydrophilic
layer may be an integral part of the coating based on
titanium oxide and constitute the outermost surface
thereof, as explained in the remainder of the text.
Coating based on titanium oxide
The coating based on titanium oxide may be exclusively
composed of titanium oxide (apart from inevitable
impurities). The titanium oxide may be amorphous or
have an at least partially crystalline structure,
especially in anatase or rutile form. The technical

effect discovered does not seem a priori to have a
connection with the photocatalytic activity since
amorphous titanium oxide coatings, the photocatalytic
activity of which is extremely low or even nonexistent,
also prevent the deposition and adhesion of mineral
soiling in the absence of water runoff. Other not very
active coatings may therefore also be used, such as
very thin titanium oxide coatings, for example having a
thickness of 1 to 5 run. A layer of crystalline titanium
oxide in anatase form, in particular having a thickness
greater than 5 nm, is however preferred in order to
give the material a sufficient photocatalytic activity
to effectively degrade the organic soiling. Preferred
thicknesses are thus from 5 to 2 0 nm, the larger
thicknesses possibly generating an undesirable coloring
and inducing longer deposition times. The presence of
the thin hydrophilic layer, insofar as its thickness is
not greater than a few nanometers, in particular 5 nm
and especially 2 nm, does not decrease the
photocatalytic activity of the material, and even seems
sometimes to increase it. Examples of particularly
advantageous titanium oxide coatings in the context of
the present invention are, for example, described in
patent application EP-A-850 204 incorporated by
reference in the present application.
The coatings based on titanium oxide may be formed by
various deposition processes, for example by the
process of chemical vapor deposition (CVD, as described
in the aforementioned application EP 850 2 04) , by the
sputtering process (application FR 2 814 094,
incorporated by reference into the present text,
presents one particular method thereof), or by "sol-
gel" type processes.
According to one embodiment of the invention, the
titanium oxide of the coating based on titanium oxide
is predominantly, or even completely, amorphous. In

this case, the material composed of a substrate thus
coated is novel and constitutes one subject of the
present invention. It may, in particular, be a
substrate coated by a layer of titanium oxide then by a
layer of silica, the two layers being obtained
successively by the sputtering process (in particular
assisted by a magnetic field - magnetron sputtering
process) and not undergoing annealing after the
deposition, that is to say no heat treatment at more
than 500°C, in particular 200°C. Another subject of the
invention is therefore a process for obtaining such a
material, comprising successive steps of deposition by
sputtering of a coating based on titanium oxide and of
a thin layer based on silicon and oxygen, but not
comprising an annealing step after the deposition.
Mixed layers
The coating based on titanium oxide may also comprise
titanium oxide mixed with another compound, especially
another oxide. Mixed oxides of titanium and one or more
oxides chosen from silicon, aluminum, magnesium or tin
oxides constitute possible embodiments of the
invention.
The titanium oxide may, in particular, be present in
the form of particles that are discernible and at least
partially crystalline dispersed in a preferably mineral
or inorganic binder. This binder is advantageously
based on silica, for example in the form of an alkali
metal silicate or of silica obtained by the sol-gel
process. The coatings based on titanium oxide described
in applications WO 97/10185 or WO 99/44954 constitute
coatings of this type that can be applied to the
present invention. Coatings based on titanium oxide
particles of nanoscale size dispersed in a binder of
mesoporous type such as described in application
WO 03/87002 are particularly advantageous when a very

high photocatalytic activity is required, especially
for applications inside buildings.
In the latter case, where the coating based on titanium
oxide comprises titanium oxide mixed with another
compound, the thin hydrophilic layer, optionally free
of titanium oxide, may be an integral part of the
coating based on titanium oxide and constitute the
outermost surface thereof. A single deposition step is
then sufficient to deposit the coating based on
titanium oxide and the thin hydrophilic layer which
surmounts it. It may be, by way of example, a coating
comprising titanium oxide particles dispersed in a
siliceous binder, the outermost surface (that is to say
a few nanometers) being mainly composed of silica, or
even being only composed of silica and therefore free
of titanium oxide.
Mixed TiO2/SiO2 layer with concentration gradient
A novel material that can be used according to the
invention is a material composed of a substrate
equipped with at least one layer whose surface forms at
least part of the outer surface of said material, said
layer comprising titanium oxide and silicon oxide. This
material is characterized in that the titanium oxide
content at said outer surface is non-zero and in that
the silicon oxide content is higher at said outer
surface than at the center of the layer.
In this embodiment of the invention, the coating based
on titanium oxide and the thin hydrophilic layer form a
single mixed layer (comprising titanium and silicon
oxides), enriched at the surface with silicon oxide.
The thin hydrophilic layer thus is an integral part of
the coating based on titanium oxide and constitutes the
outermost surface thereof.

The silicon oxide content at the outer surface of the
layer is greater than the silicon oxide content at the
center of the layer, and even advantageously greater
than the silicon oxide content in the part of the layer
closest to the substrate. The titanium oxide content at
the outer surface is itself preferably less than the
titanium oxide content at the center of the layer, or
even less than the titanium oxide content in the part
of the layer closest to the substrate.
Advantageously, the silicon oxide content increases
continuously in the thickness of the layer from the
center of the layer, especially from the part closest
to the substrate, up to the outer surface. It is then
possible to refer to layers that have a SiO2 content
gradient that increases in the thickness of the layer,
or else mixed layers with a composition gradient. The
term "continuously" should be understood, in the
mathematical sense of the term, to mean that the SiO2
content is a continuous function of the distance to the
substrate. The TiO2 content itself decreases in
correlation with the thickness of the layer, from the
center of the layer to the outer surface, preferably
from the part closest to the substrate to the outer
surface, continuously.
The silicon oxide content at the outer surface is
advantageously greater than or equal to 5 wt%, or even
10 wt% or 15 wt%, and even 20 or 25 wt% and/or less
than or equal to 5 0 wt%, or 4 0 wt%, or even 3 5 wt% or
30 wt%. The silicon oxide content at the center of the
layer is itself preferably less than or equal to
15 wt%, or 10 wt% and even 5 wt%. These layers have a
very marked enrichment of silicon oxide at the surface;
however, contents that do not exceed 50 wt% are
preferred as they make it possible to combine low dust
accumulation with high photocatalytic activity and
super-hydrophilicity, as explained in the remainder of

the text. Even higher silicon oxide contents at the
outer surface (more than 5 0%, or more than 7 0% and even
more than 9 0%) make it possible to obtain an even lower
level of dust accumulation, which is accompanied
however by a degradation of the photocatalytic
activity.
The layer according to the invention is preferably
solely composed of titanium oxide and silicon oxide,
apart from inevitable impurities (for example, elements
originating from the substrate).
The thickness of the layer is preferably between 3 and
200 nm, or even between 3 and 100 nm. Thicknesses
between 3 and 30 nm, especially between 5 and 2 0 nm and
even between 5 and 15 nm are preferred. This is
because, for thickness values that are too small, the
desired effect of low dust accumulation is only
slightly obtained. Thicknesses that are too large do
not make it possible to improve this effect and
generate a higher cost, a longer deposition time and an
optical appearance of the layer that is too visible, in
particular undesirable yellow tints. Large thicknesses,
especially greater than or equal to 3 0 nm, or even
50 nm may be appreciated if a high photocatalytic
activity is required, for example for applications as
interior glazing, that receives little ultraviolet
radiation.
The layer comprising titanium oxide and silicon oxide
is advantageously the only layer conferring
photocatalytic or self-cleaning properties on the
material. In particular, the layer according to the
invention is preferably not deposited itself on a
photocatalytic layer based on titanium oxide as such a
multilayer in no way improves the properties of the
material.

Mixed TiO2/SiO2 layers have been described in the prior
art, in particular in application WO 97/03029. This
application specifically describes layers having a
refractive index gradient that varies in the thickness
of the layer and that decreases from the zone closest
to the substrate to the zone closest to the surface.
These layers, including mixed TiO2/SiO2 layers, are used
as intermediate layers in multilayers for improving
their optical appearance. They are surmounted by at
least one electrically conductive or low-emissivity
layer and therefore do not form the outer part of the
material.
Process for obtaining mixed TiO2/SiO2 layers having a
composition gradient
The mixed layers having a composition gradient
according to the invention may be obtained by the
process described in WO 97/03029. This chemical vapor
deposition (CVD) process uses a nozzle that extends
transversely to the running axis of the substrate (in
particular of the glass that is in the form of a ribbon
obtained by the float glass process) and that has two
slits for injection of precursor gases of different
compositions and that are sized so that partial and
gradual mixing between the two gas streams is produced
in the deposition zone.
The inventors have however developed a chemical vapor
deposition process that is more astute as it uses a
conventional nozzle, that only has a single gas
injection slit and makes it possible to obtain all
sorts of mixed layers having a composition gradient,
including the TiO2/SiO2 layers described above.
This process for chemical vapor deposition onto a
substrate running along an axis, and using a nozzle
that extends transversely to the running axis of said

substrate and that has a single slit, is characterized
in that at least two gaseous precursors that do not
react together are injected simultaneously via said
single slit, said precursors having decomposition
temperatures that are intrinsically or extrinsically
sufficiently different to form a layer in which the
content of the oxide whose precursor has the lowest
decomposition temperature decreases continuously in the
thickness of the layer.
Another subject of the invention is a process for
obtaining a material composed of a substrate equipped
with at least one layer comprising titanium oxide and
silicon oxide, according to which said layer is
deposited by chemical vapor deposition (CVD) onto said
substrate running along an axis, said deposition being
carried out using a nozzle that extends transversely to
the run axis of said substrate and that has a single
slit, gaseous precursors of titanium oxide and of
silicon oxide that do not react together being injected
simultaneously via said single slit, and such that at
least one titanium oxide precursor has a decomposition
temperature that is intrinsically or extrinsically
sufficiently lower than the decomposition temperature
of at least one silicon oxide precursor to form a layer
in which the silicon oxide content increases
continuously in the thickness of the layer.
The inventors have actually realized that by a suitable
choice of the precursors, and more specifically by a
suitable choice of their respective decomposition
temperatures, it was possible to obtain a layer having
a composition gradient using a conventional chemical
vapor phase deposition nozzle. When the decomposition
temperatures are not sufficiently different from one
another, a mixed layer is formed, which has a
substantially homogeneous composition throughout the
thickness of the layer. In the particular case of the

TiO2/SiO2 layers according to the invention, too small a
difference between the decomposition temperatures of
the various precursors does not lead to the surface
enrichment in silica that is desired and that is at the
origin of good dust accumulation properties. The
difference needed between the decomposition
temperatures of the precursors obviously depends on a
large number of parameters such as the chemical nature
of the layers to be formed or the temperature of the
substrate during the deposition. It must be adapted on
a case by case basis by a person skilled in the art.
The decomposition temperatures of the precursors may be
intrinsic to the chosen precursor, or be modified
selectively by addition of a compound that inhibits, or
alternatively accelerates, the deposition of the
precursor. It is possible, for example, to add ethylene
(C2H4) to the precursors in order to slow down the
deposition of SiO2, in particular when the SiO2
precursor is tetraethoxysilane (TEOS), which makes it
possible to have a higher composition gradient.
The particular process in which the precursors are
injected together is also preferred as the layers that
it makes it possible to obtain are more effective in
terms of anti-dust properties than the layers obtained
by the process described in application WO 97/03029,
probably due to a different microstructure.
For reasons of ease of use on an industrial scale,
preferably a single titanium oxide precursor and a
single silicon oxide precursor are injected. In order
to obtain a layer having a well defined composition
gradient, the difference between the respective
decomposition temperatures of the titanium oxide and
silicon oxide precursors is preferably at least 50°C,
or 7 5°C, and even 100°C or 150°C.

By way of example, the TiO2 and SiO2 precursors may
respectively be tetraiospropyl titanate (TiPT) and
tetraethoxysilane (TEOS), which have the advantages of
being inexpensive and non-toxic. TiPT has a
decomposition temperature of around 300°C, i.e. around
100 to 150°C less than TEOS.
The respective amounts of TiO2 and SiO2 precursors
introduced may be defined by the Ti/ (Ti + Si) molar
ratio calculated from the molar amounts of Ti and Si
atoms introduced (present in the gas phase). This molar
ratio is not found as is in the layer due to the
differences in yield between the precursors.
This ratio is preferably between 0.85 and 0.96,
especially between 0.90 and 0.93. This is because it
has been noted that in this ratio range, the product
obtained made it possible to combine the properties of
low dust accumulation with a photocatalytic activity
and a photoinduced super-hydrophilicity close to those
of a product comprising a single layer of titanium
oxide crystallized in anatase form.
When the Ti/(Ti + Si) ratio is higher, close to 1, the
properties obtained approach those of a substrate
coated by a single titanium oxide layer. The material
obtained therefore has a high dust accumulation, and is
consequently covered with mineral soiling in the
absence of water runoff.
When, on the other hand, the Ti/(Si + Ti) ratio is
lower, in particular around 0.7 or 0.8, or even less,
the surface of the layer is highly enriched with
silicon and the layers obtained have a substantially
reduced, or even nonexistent, photocatalytic activity
and even lose the photoinduced super-hydrophilicity
character. This phenomenon could be due to the fact
that the presence of silica in too high an amount

within the mixed layer disturbs the titanium oxide
crystallization properties, giving rise to amorphous
layers or, in any case, layers that are not very
crystalline. Such layers may nevertheless be used
within the meaning of the present invention, as the
dust (mineral soiling) is only slightly deposited and
only slightly adheres to their surface. These layers,
the surface of which is extremely enriched with silica
but still has a high titanium oxide content, are
therefore used all the same due to their ability not to
be covered by mineral soiling.
The layers for which the Ti/(Si + Ti) molar ratio is
optimized make it possible, on the other hand, to
combine all the advantages: low dust accumulation (same
level as for lower molar ratios) , high photocatalytic
activity and photoinduced super-hydrophilicity.
When the substrate is made of glass, and in particular
when it is a sheet of glass formed by pouring molten
glass onto a molten tin bath (process known as the
"float" process), the chemical vapor deposition process
is preferably carried out continuously, at the outlet
of the float bath, on a substrate whose temperature is
usually between 580°C and 630°C.
Another subject of the invention is a material capable
of being obtained by the process according to the
invention described previously. The antisoiling
properties obtained when the surface of the layer
comprising silicon oxide and titanium oxide forms at
least part of the outer surface of the material are, in
effect, particularly attractive. Considering the
difficulty in precisely studying the microstructure of
the layers obtained according to this process, it is
not however possible to structurally define these
preferred materials. The various preferred
characteristics of the material described previously

(presence of a sublayer, thicknesses, etc.) also apply
to this material.
The layers of the materials according to the invention
may also be obtained by other deposition processes, for
example a magnetically-enhanced sputtering process
(magnetron sputtering process) in which the substrate
is successively exposed to the bombardment originating
from TiO2 targets increasingly enriched with SiO2.
Types of substrates
The substrates used within the scope of the present
invention may be of mineral nature, especially based on
glass, ceramic or glass-ceramic, or else of organic
nature. In the latter case, various rigid or flexible
plastics may be used such as polymethyl methacrylate
(PMMA), polycarbonate (PC), polypropylene,
polyurethane, polyvinyl butyral, polyethylene glycol
terephthalate, polybutylene glycol terephthalate, and
ionomer resins such as a copolymer of
ethylene/(meth)acrylic acid neutralized by a polyamine,
a cycloolefin copolymer such as ethylene/norbornene or
ethylene/cyclopentadiene copolymers, a polycarbonate/polyester
copolymer, an ethylene/vinyl
acetate copolymer and the like, alone or as blends. Use
may also be made of substrates obtained by
polymerization of diethylene glycol bis(allyl
carbonate) (sold under the trade mark CR39® by PPG
Industries Inc.), or substrates based on a (meth)allyl
or (meth)acrylic polymer, (more particularly those
obtained from monomers or prepolymers derived from
bisphenol A, used alone or as a blend with other
copolymerizable monomers), based on poly(thio)urethane,
or else based on polystyrene or diallyl phthalate
resin.
Sublayers

At least one sublayer is preferably inserted between
the substrate and the coating based on titanium oxide.
This sublayer is itself advantageously in contact with
the substrate and/or the coating based on titanium
oxide.
When the substrate contains elements capable of
migrating to the inside of the layer based on titanium
oxide and of disturbing its properties, it is, in
effect, preferable to insert, between said substrate
and said layer based on titanium oxide, a layer that
forms a barrier to the migration of these elements.
This is the case, in particular, when the substrate,
for example when it is a sheet of sodium-lime silicate
glass or a ceramic coated with a glaze, contains alkali
metal ions such as lithium, potassium or sodium.
An alkali metal barrier sublayer is therefore
preferably positioned directly under the coating based
on titanium oxide, which has the role of preventing the
migration of the alkali metal ions possibly contained
in the substrate within the layer comprising titanium
oxide. A barrier layer such as, for example, a layer
comprising SiO2, SiOC, Al2O3 or SnO2 is particularly
suitable for preserving the photocatalytic activity of
the titanium oxide.
The alkali metal barrier sublayer is advantageously a
layer of SiOC (silicon oxycarbide), preferably
deposited by CVD (chemical vapor deposition) directly
onto the substrate. The SiOC sublayer then
advantageously has, on its surface, regularly spaced
bumps that preferably have a width at the base of
around 60 to 120 nm and a height of around 20 to 50 nm.
This is because it has been observed that the technical
effect which consists in preventing the deposition of
mineral soiling on its surface was amplified when the

deposition of the coating based on titanium oxide
(especially when it is a mixed TiO2/SiO2 having a
concentration gradient) was carried out on such a
textured surface. The reason for this is, for the time
being, completely unexplained.
It may also be desirable to position at least one
sublayer between the substrate and the coating based on
titanium oxide, for example in order to reduce a
reflection factor or a coloration in reflection that
are judged to be too high. It may be, for example, a
layer or a multilayer whose thicknesses and refractive
indices are such that the assembly formed by these
sublayers and the coating based on titanium oxide forms
an anti-reflection multilayer, in the sense where the
reflection factor obtained is less than that of the
substrate.
Applications
The material according to the invention has the
advantage of preventing the deposition of mineral
soiling (dust accumulation) and therefore of not being
soiled in the absence of water runoff, in particular
during exposure that is outside but is sheltered from
the rain, therefore when it is subjected to a cycle
characterized by the alternation of solar illumination
during the day and the absence of illumination during
the night. It is during a cycle of several
alternations, especially after several months of
exposure (2, or 4 months, or more), that the advantage,
relative to a substrate equipped with a photocatalytic
coating that is uncoated or is based on TiO2 alone, is
revealed. Such situations are frequent, in particular
in the case of buildings that have cornices, overhangs
or sunshades in front of or above glazed walls, the
latter therefore not being subjected to rainwater
runoff. Use of the material in outside zones protected

from the rain or in geographical zones that very rarely
experience precipitation is therefore particularly
advantageous.
Another subject of the invention is the use of a
material according to the invention as a material that
has the property of not being soiled when it is placed
in outside exposure in zones that are protected from
the rain or in geographical zones that very rarely
experience precipitation.
The very recently discovered technical effect also
enables use of the material inside a building, for
example in the form of interior glazing or a display
screen such as a screen of the LCD (Liquid Crystal
Display), plasma or cathode-ray tube type, to prevent
dust accumulation on the screen. It is also possible to
use the material according to the invention inside a
transport vehicle (motor vehicle, train, plane, etc.)
for example, as a windshield or side window of a motor
vehicle. It should furthermore be noted that the
properties of the material according to the invention
are not affected by toughening or bending.
The invention will be better understood with the aid of
the following exemplary embodiments, which illustrate
the invention without however limiting it.
Example 1
A glazing panel, sold by Saint-Gobain Glass under the
name SGG Bioclean® and composed of a soda-lime silicate
glass substrate equipped on one of its surfaces with a
thin layer of SiOC acting as a barrier to the migration
of alkali metals covered by a titanium oxide coating
with a thickness of 15 nm, crystallized in anatase form
and obtained by the chemical vapor deposition (CVD)
process, served as comparative example Cl. This glazing

panel was of the self cleaning type in the presence of
solar radiation and rainwater runoff due to the
photocatalytic and super-hydrophilic properties of the
titanium oxide, which enabled it to degrade the organic
soiling and to remove the mineral soiling under water,
especially rain, runoff.
A second comparative example (C2) was constituted by a
glazing panel made of uncoated soda-lime silicate
glass.
In order to produce example 1 according to the
invention, the glazing panel from comparative
example Cl was in turn coated with a very thin layer of
silica doped with aluminum in an amount of 8 at%,
deposited by the magnetically-enhanced sputtering
process, sometimes referred to as "magnetron
sputtering" process. The thickness of this unannealed
thin hydrophilic layer was around 2 nm.
These three glazing panels were exposed to outside
conditions for 4 months under a transparent canopy,
consequently sheltered from the rain but not from solar
radiation. They were subjected to a cycle characterized
by the alternation of solar illumination during the day
and the absence of illumination during the night.
After exposure, the three glazing panels were observed.
The two comparative samples Cl and C2 both had a very
large quantity of extremely adherent mineral dust on
the exposed surface. The glazing panel according to the
invention itself had no notable dust accumulation.
Example 2
Deposited onto a soda-lime silicate glass substrate
were an alkali metal barrier sublayer made of SiOC with
a thickness of 50 nm via a chemical vapor deposition

process starting from SiH4, ethylene and optionally an
oxidizing compound, according to the process described
in application EP 0 518 755. This sublayer was
naturally textured, and had, at its surface, bumps
whose width at the base was around 100 nm and the
height around 3 0 nm.
Deposited onto this sublayer were mixed layers of TiO2
and SiO2 via a chemical vapor deposition (CVD) process
using a standard spray nozzle (equipped with a single
slit). Injected through this single slit were the
precursors of TiO2 (tetraisopropyl titanate TiPT) and
of SiO2 (tetraethoxysilane, TEOS) , the Ti/(Ti + Si)
molar ratio in the gas phase varying as a function of
the tests between 0.67 and 1. The value of 1
corresponded to the comparative test in which TEOS was
not injected. The layers obtained had a thickness of
around 9 to 12 nm depending on the tests.
Considering their small thickness and their particular
texturization (due to the presence of the SiOC
sublayer), it was difficult to elucidate, with
precision, the structure of these layers. The Si/Ti
molar ratio at the surface of the layer (the first
nanometers) was measured by the method known as ESCA
(Electron Spectroscopy for Chemical Analysis) also
known as XPS (X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy). The
local composition of the layers as a function of the
thickness was studied by SIMS (Secondary Ion Mass
Spectroscopy).
The following elements emerged from the latter study:
the layer for which the Ti/(Ti + Si) ratio was
equal to 0.92, therefore weakly enriched with silicon,
had a very low content of silicon oxide (at most a few
percent by weight) at the center of the layer, this
content greatly and continuously increasing on

approaching the outer surface of the material, to reach
around 2 5 to 3 0% by weight; and
the layer for which the Ti/(Ti + Si) ratio was
equal to 0.67 had a silicon oxide content of around 5
to 10% by weight at the center of the layer, this
content greatly and continuously increasing on
approaching the outer surface of the material, to reach
around 7 0 to 75% by weight. The outermost surface of
the layer therefore predominantly contained silica. The
weight content of titanium oxide therefore decreased
continuously in the thickness of the layer from the
center (90-95%) to the surface (25-30%).
The photocatalytic, photoinduced hydrophilicity and
dust accumulation properties were measured as described
below.
The photocatalytic activity was determined by measuring
the color variation, after exposure to ultraviolet
radiation, of an ink layer deposited on the outer
surface of the material. This ink, described in
application EP 1 601 462, was composed of a colored
indicator such as methylene blue, a sacrificial
electron donor organic molecule and a neutral polymer
matrix, and had the particularity of detecting redox
reactions at the surface of the titanium oxide and of
changing color as a function of the intensity of these
reactions. The irradiation of the titanium oxide in
effect generated an electron-hole pair, the electron
having made the colored indicator react via a reduction
reaction and the hole having recombined with an
electron originating from the electron donor organic
molecule. A few drops of ink were deposited on the
surface of the material then a sheet of glass that was
transparent to ultraviolet radiation was sealed over
said surface so that the ink covered the entire surface
homogeneously. During irradiation of the surface via

ultraviolet radiation, the color variation of the ink
was quantified by spectrophotometry in terms of
variation of the component a* in the La*b* color-
measuring system. The results were expressed in
arbitrary units taking the comparative example in which
the silica precursor was not injected as the base
(value fixed arbitrarily at 100).
The dust accumulation, or the ability of the material
to be covered with mineral soiling adhering to its
surface, was measured as follows. The samples were
irradiated for 10 hours by ultraviolet radiation (UV-A
type, power 30 W/m2) to activate their surface (make it
hydrophilic). In an environmental chamber in the
absence of UV illumination, the surface of the samples
was then covered with calcium carbonate particles of
less than 50 microns in diameter that simulated dust.
After 15 minutes, the material was placed in a vertical
position to remove the excess dust and the surface was
then cleaned using a compressed air jet, so that only
the dust adhering remained on the surface of the
material. This procedure was repeated cumulatively up
to six repeats at a rate of one test per hour then the
percentage of the surface still occupied by dust was
measured by image analysis techniques. The comparative
sample (corresponding to a Ti/(Ti + Si) ratio of 1)
being taken as the reference (base 100), the results
were expressed as a percentage of the surface still
occupied by adherent dust relative to this reference.
The photoinduced hydrophilicity properties were
determined by measurements of the water contact angle.
Two types of measurement were carried out: measurements
taken after illumination by ultraviolet radiation then
storage for 1 to 7 days in darkness, and measurements
taken after an exposure time to ultraviolet rays
ranging from 15 minutes to 26 hours.

Table 1 below collates the results of the
photocatalytic activity and dust accumulation of the
various examples. Tables 2 and 3 for their part collate
the hydrophilicity results.



These results show that an enrichment of the silica
layer considerably improves the dust accumulation
properties, in the sense where two or three times less
dust adheres to the surface of the material compared to
the case where the layer only comprises titanium oxide.
This effect is still obtained for small amounts of
silicon precursors introduced (Ti/(Ti + Si) ratio of
0.92, i.e. only 8 mol% of silicon), therefore for low
silicon contents in the mixed layer; the subsequent
increase in the silicon content only has a small effect
on this property. On the other hand, the presence of
silicon in the layer rapidly degrades its
photocatalytic activity, until practically canceling it
out. The effects of low dust accumulation and
photocatalytic activity are therefore completely
decorrelated. It can also be noted that the addition of
a silicon precursor very significantly increases the
Si/Ti ratio at the surface of the material, this ratio
being equal to around 2 when the silicon precursor is
only added in an amount equal to half the titanium
precursor content.
In terms of hydrophilicity, table 2 shows that the
sample for which the Ti/(Ti + Si) ratio is 0.92 has a
photoinduced hydrophilic character that decreases when
the material is subjected to a long period of darkness,
to an extent comparable to the performance of the
comparative sample that is free of silicon. The
hydrophilicity may then be again rapidly obtained by
subjecting the sample to ultraviolet radiation
(table 3) . On the other hand, the addition of higher
silicon contents in the layer very substantially
degrades the photoinduced hydrophilicity properties
since the samples for which the Ti/(Ti + Si) ratio is
0.85 or less are hydrophobic and remain so even after a

new illumination under ultraviolet radiation (see table
3). These results therefore again demonstrate that the
low dust accumulation of the materials according to the
invention is completely independent of the photoinduced
hydrophilicity properties.
The materials according to the invention therefore have
the property of preventing or at least slowing down the
deposition of mineral soiling on their surface. When
low silicon contents are used, this property is
moreover coupled with the known properties of the
titanium oxide which are the photocatalysis and the
photoinduced hydrophilicity. Such materials are
therefore particularly desirable due to their property
of not being soiled when they are placed in outside
exposure in zones protected from the rain or in
geographical zones that very rarely experience
precipitation.
All the glazing panels from example 2 were exposed for
4 months in outside conditions similar to those
described for example 1.
After exposure, the glazing panels according to the
invention did not have any notable dust accumulation.
On the other hand, the comparative glazing panel
(corresponding to the Ti/(Ti + Si) ratio of 1) was dirty
and had a large amount of extremely adherent mineral
dust on its surface.
The preceding description makes it possible to
illustrate some possible embodiments of the invention.
It is clearly understood that this description is not
however limiting and that a person skilled in the art
is able to achieve other variants of the invention
without however going outside the scope thereof.

We claim:
1. A process of preventing the deposition of mineral
soiling on the outer surface of a material in the
absence of water runoff, wherein a material composed
of a substrate equipped with a coating based on
titanium oxide surmounted by a thin hydrophilic layer
forming at least one part of the outer surface of said
material and that is not composed of titanium oxide is
used.
2. The process as claimed in claim 1, such that the thin
hydrophilic layer has a thickness of leSS than 10 nm,
preferable between 1 and 2 nm.
3. The process as claimed in claim 1 or 2, such that the
thin hydrophilic layer is capable of creating, in the
presence of ambient moisture and owing to the
underlying presence of the titanium oxide, a hydration
layer that is less dense than liquid water.
4. The process as claimed in one of the preceding claims,
such that the thin hydrophilic layer is based on
silicon and oxygen.
5. The process as claims in the preceding claim, such
that the thin hydrophilic layer is made of silica
(Sio2) , optionally doped with atoms such as aluminum
(Al) or zirconium (Zr).

6. The process as claimed in one of the preceding claims,
such that the coating based on the titanium oxide is
exclusively composed of titanium oxide that is
amorphous or that has an at least partially-
crystalline structure, especially in anatase or
runtile form.
7. The process as claimed in one of claims 1 to 5, such
that the coating based on titanium oxide comprises
discernible titanium oxide particle that are at least
partially crystalline and dispersed in a binder.
8. The process as claimed in the preceding claim, such
that the thin hydrophilic layer is an integral part of
the coating based on titanium oxide and constitutes
the outermost surface thereof.
9. The process as claimed in one of claims 1 to 4, such
that the coating based on titanium oxide and the thin
hydrophilic layer form a layer comprising titanium
oxide and silicon oxide, the titanium oxide content at
said outer surface being non-zero and the silicon
oxide content being higher at the outer surface than
at the center of the layer.
10. The process as claimed in one of the preceding
claims, such that an alkali metal barrier sublayer is
positioned directly under the coating based on
titanium oxide.

11. The process of a material composed of a substrate
equipped with a coating based on titanium oxide
surmounted by a thin hydrophilic layer forming at
least one part of the outer surface of said material
and that is not composed of titanium oxide, as a
material that has property of not being soiled when it
is placed in outside exposure in zones that are
protected from the rain or in geographical zones that
very rarely experience precipitation.
12. A material composed of a substrate equipped with
a coating based on titanium oxide surmounted by a thin
hydrophilic layer forming at least one part

of the outer surface of said material and that is
not composed of titanium oxide, characterized in
that said thin hydrophilic layer is capable of
creating, in the presence of ambient moisture and
owing to the underlying presence of the titanium
oxide, a hydration layer that is less dense than
liquid water.
13. The material composed of a substrate equipped with
a coating based on titanium oxide surmounted by a
thin hydrophilic layer forming at least one part
of the outer surface of said material and that is
not composed of titanium oxide, characterized in
that the titanium oxide is predominantly
amorphous.
14. A material composed of a substrate equipped with
at least one layer whose surface forms at least
one part of the outer surface of said material,
said layer comprising titanium oxide and silicon
oxide, characterized in that the titanium oxide
content at said outer surface is non-zero and in
that the silicon oxide content is higher at said
outer surface than at the center of the layer.
15. The material as claimed in the preceding claim,
such that the silicon oxide content increases
continuously in the thickness of the layer from
the center of the layer, especially from the part
closest to the substrate, up to the outer surface.
16. The material as claimed in claim 14 or 15, such
that the thickness of the layer is between 3 and
30 nm, preferably between 5 and 20 nm.
17. The material as claimed in one of claims 14 to 16,
such that the silicon oxide content in the part of
the layer closest to the substrate is non-zero.

18. The material as claimed in one of claims 14 to 17,
such that an alkali metal barrier sublayer is
. positioned directly under the layer comprising
titanium oxide and silicon oxide.
19. The material as claimed in the preceding claim,
such that the alkali metal barrier sublayer is a
SiOC layer, preferably deposited by CVD directly
onto the substrate.
20. The material as claimed in the preceding claim,
such that the SiOC sublayer has, on its surface,
regularly spaced bumps that preferably have a
width at the base of around 60 to 12 0 nm and a
height of around 2 0 to 50 nm.
21. A process for obtaining a material composed of a
substrate equipped with at least one layer
comprising titanium oxide and silicon oxide,
according to which said layer is deposited by
chemical vapor deposition (CVD) onto said
substrate running along an axis, said deposition
being carried out using a nozzle that extends
transversely to the run axis of said substrate and
that has a single slit, gaseous precursors of
titanium oxide and of silicon oxide that do not
react together being injected simultaneously via
said single slit, and such that at least one
titanium oxide precursor has a decomposition
temperature that is intrinsically or extrinsically
sufficiently lower than the decomposition
temperature of at least one silicon oxide
precursor to form a layer in which the silicon
oxide content increases continuously in the
thickness of the layer.
22. The process as claimed in the preceding claim,

such that a single titanium oxide precursor and a
single silicon oxide precursor are injected.
23 . The process as claimed in the preceding claim,
such that the difference between the respective
decomposition temperatures of the titanium oxide
and silicon oxide precursors is at least 50°C.
24. The process as claimed in the preceding claim,
such that the silicon oxide and titanium oxide
precursors are respectively tetraethoxysilane
(TEOS) and tetraisopropyl titanate (TiPT).
25. The process as claimed in one of the preceding
process claims, such that the Ti/(Ti + Si) molar
ratio calculated from the molar amounts of Ti and
Si atoms introduced (present in the gas phase) is
between 0.85 and 0.96, preferably between 0.90 and
0.93.
26. A material capable of being obtained according to
the process of one of the preceding process
claims.
27. A material as claimed in one of the preceding
material claims, such that the substrate is made
of glass.
28. A glazing panel or display screen incorporating at
least one material as claimed in the preceding
claim.

The invention relates to a material comprising a substrate which is provided
with a titanium oxide-based coating which is topped with a thin hydrophilic
layer. The aforementioned thin hydrophilic layer forms at least part of the
external surface of the material and does not comprise titanium oxide. The
invention relates to the use of said material in order to prevent mineral
fouling from being deposited on the external surface in the absence of water
runoff.

Documents:

01872-kolnp-2008-abstract.pdf

01872-kolnp-2008-claims.pdf

01872-kolnp-2008-correspondence others.pdf

01872-kolnp-2008-description complete.pdf

01872-kolnp-2008-form 1.pdf

01872-kolnp-2008-form 2.pdf

01872-kolnp-2008-form 3.pdf

01872-kolnp-2008-form 5.pdf

01872-kolnp-2008-gpa.pdf

01872-kolnp-2008-international publication.pdf

01872-kolnp-2008-international search report.pdf

01872-kolnp-2008-pct request form.pdf

01872-kolnp-2008-priority document.pdf

01872-kolnp-2008-translated copy of priority document.pdf

1872-KOLNP-2008-(06-11-2013)-ABSTRACT.pdf

1872-KOLNP-2008-(06-11-2013)-ANNEXURE TO FORM 3.pdf

1872-KOLNP-2008-(06-11-2013)-CLAIMS.pdf

1872-KOLNP-2008-(06-11-2013)-CORRESPONDENCE.pdf

1872-KOLNP-2008-(06-11-2013)-OTHERS.pdf

1872-KOLNP-2008-(06-11-2013)-PA.pdf

1872-KOLNP-2008-(06-11-2013)-PETITION UNDER RULE 137.pdf

1872-KOLNP-2008-(26-11-2012)-CORRESPONDENCE.pdf

1872-kolnp-2008-CANCELLED PAGES.pdf

1872-KOLNP-2008-CORRESPONDENCE OTHERS-1.1.pdf

1872-kolnp-2008-CORRESPONDENCE.pdf

1872-kolnp-2008-EXAMINATION REPORT.pdf

1872-kolnp-2008-FORM 18-1.1.pdf

1872-kolnp-2008-form 18.pdf

1872-kolnp-2008-GPA.pdf

1872-kolnp-2008-GRANTED-ABSTRACT.pdf

1872-kolnp-2008-GRANTED-CLAIMS.pdf

1872-kolnp-2008-GRANTED-DESCRIPTION (COMPLETE).pdf

1872-kolnp-2008-GRANTED-FORM 1.pdf

1872-kolnp-2008-GRANTED-FORM 2.pdf

1872-kolnp-2008-GRANTED-FORM 3.pdf

1872-kolnp-2008-GRANTED-FORM 5.pdf

1872-kolnp-2008-GRANTED-LETTER PATENT.pdf

1872-kolnp-2008-GRANTED-SPECIFICATION-COMPLETE.pdf

1872-kolnp-2008-INTERNATIONAL PUBLICATION.pdf

1872-kolnp-2008-INTERNATIONAL SEARCH REPORT & OTHERS.pdf

1872-KOLNP-2008-OTHER.pdf

1872-kolnp-2008-OTHERS-1.1.pdf

1872-kolnp-2008-PETITION UNDER RULE 137.pdf

1872-kolnp-2008-REPLY TO EXAMINATION REPORT.pdf

1872-kolnp-2008-TRANSLATED COPY OF PRIORITY DOCUMENT.pdf


Patent Number 263713
Indian Patent Application Number 1872/KOLNP/2008
PG Journal Number 47/2014
Publication Date 21-Nov-2014
Grant Date 17-Nov-2014
Date of Filing 09-May-2008
Name of Patentee SAINT-GOBAIN GLASS FRANCE
Applicant Address 18, AVENUE D'ALSACE, F-92400 COURBEVOIE
Inventors:
# Inventor's Name Inventor's Address
1 ROYER, EDDY 8, BOULEVARD VOLTAIER, F-92600 ASNIERES
2 KHARCHENKO, ANDRLY 17, RUE SAINTE GENEVIEVE, F-91120 PALAISEAU
3 LELARAGE, ANNE 129 BOULEVARD DIDEROT DIDEROT, F-75012 PARIS
4 BARTHEL, ETIENNE 7 RUE AUGUSTE DEMMLER, F-92340 BOURG LA REINE
5 NGHIEM, BERNARD 8 CHEMIN DU TOUR DE VILLE, F-60190 ARSY
6 SONDERGARD, ELIN 41 RUE FONTAINE GRELOT, RESIDENCE LE PETIT CHAMBORD, BATIMENT 22, F-92340 BOURG LA REINE
7 GARREC, RONAN 34 RUE JEAN JACQUES ROUSSEAU, F-92600 ASNIERES SUR SEINE
8 ZAGDOUN, GEORGES 32, RUE LEON MAURICE NORDMANN, F-92250 LA GARENNE COLOMBES
PCT International Classification Number C03C 17/34
PCT International Application Number PCT/FR2006/051074
PCT International Filing date 2006-10-20
PCT Conventions:
# PCT Application Number Date of Convention Priority Country
1 05/53,203 2005-10-21 France
2 06/52,877 2006-07-07 France