Title of Invention

METHOD AND APPARATUS FOR MANAGING A COMMUNICATION LINK

Abstract A method and apparatus of managing a communication link may include monitoring at least one of a plurality of physical links and a plurality of communication links associated with a plurality of data communications, calculating a statistical quantity of a noise element of a selected one or more of at least one of the plurality of physical links and the plurality of communication links at a plurality of first time intervals, measuring the noise clement of the selected one or more of at least one of the plurality of physical links and the plurality of communication links at a second time interval, determining whether the noise element measured at the second time interval has exceeded a first noise threshold, and communicating an alert notification when the first noise threshold is exceeded.
Full Text METHOD AND APPARATUS FOR MANAGING A
COMMUNICATION LINK
BACKGROUND OF INVENTION
[0001] In any communication system, high levels of noise may result in
data loss or significant degradation of the quality of data such that
the resulting data is unusable. For example, in video or voice
applications, noise may cause video data to be unviewable and
voice data to be inaudible. Further in the prior art, data traffic that
experiences significant noise conditions may require boosting signal
strength, which reduces system capacity, or retries, which expends
limited network resources.
[0002] Current methods of detecting noisy communication links are overly
simplistic given the complex and varying nature of noise
encountered. For example, current methods of detecting noise do
not take into account the Gaussian distribution of noise and its
accompanying unpredictability.
[0003] Accordingly, there is a need not met in the prior art, for a method
and apparatus of monitoring noise on a communication link.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0004] Representative elements, operational features, applications and/or
advantages of the present invention reside inter alia in the details of
I

construction and operation as more fully hereafter depicted,
described and claimed - reference being made to the
accompanying drawings forming a part hereof, wherein like
numerals refer to like parts throughout. Other elements, operational
features, applications and/or advantages will become apparent in
light of certain exemplary embodiments recited in the Detailed
Description, wherein:
[0005] FIG. 1 representatively illustrates a simplified block diagram of a
communication system in accordance with an exemplary
embodiment of the present invention; and
[0006] FIG.'s 2A and 2A representatively illustrate a flow diagram with
exemplary steps associated with a method of the invention in
accordance with an exemplary embodiment of the present
invention.
[0007] Elements in the Figures are illustrated for simplicity and clarity and
have not necessarily been drawn to scale. For example, the
dimensions of some of the elements in the Figures may be
exaggerated relative to other elements to help improve
understanding of various embodiments of the present invention.
Furthermore, the terms "first", "second", and the like herein, if any,
are used inter alia for distinguishing between similar elements and
not necessarily for describing a sequential or chronological order.
Moreover, the terms "front", "back", "top", "bottom", "over", "under",
and the like in the Description and/or in the Claims, if any, are
2

generally employed for descriptive purposes and not necessarily for
comprehensively describing exclusive relative position. Any of the
preceding terms so used may be interchanged under appropriate
circumstances such that various embodiments of the invention
described herein may be capable of operation in other
configurations and/or orientations than those explicitly illustrated or
otherwise described.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF EXEMPLARY EMBODIMENTS
[0008] The following representative descriptions of the present invention
generally relate to exemplary embodiments and the inventor's
conception of the best mode, and are not intended to limit the
applicability or configuration of the invention in any way. Rather,
the following description is intended to provide convenient
illustrations for implementing various embodiments of the invention.
As will become apparent, changes may be made in the function
and/or arrangement of any of the elements described in the
disclosed exemplary embodiments without departing from the spirit
and scope of the invention.
[0009] For clarity of explanation, the embodiments of the present invention
are presented, in part, as comprising individual functional blocks.
The functions represented by these blocks may be provided
through the use of either shared or dedicated hardware, including,
but not limited to, hardware capable of executing software. The
3

present invention is not limited to implementation by any particular
set of elements (hardware or software), and the description herein
is merely representational of one embodiment.
[0010] Software blocks that perform embodiments of the present invention
can be part of computer program modules comprising computer
instructions, such control algorithms that are stored in a computer-
readable medium such as memory. Computer instructions can
instruct processors to perform any methods described below. In
other embodiments, additional modules could be provided as
needed.
[0011] A detailed description of an exemplary application is provided as a
specific enabling disclosure that may be generalized to any
application of the disclosed system, device and method for
monitoring noise on a communication link in accordance with
various embodiments of the present invention. In an embodiment,
the invention provides a method and apparatus to derive statistical
characteristics of a noise source and adjust communication link
alarming and removal thresholds.
[0012] In an embodiment, data, as used herein in this document, may refer
to any type of numeric, voice, video, audio-visual, or script data, or
any type of source or object code, or any other suitable information
in any appropriate format that may be communicated from one point
to another.
4

[0013] Physical 'link' or 'span' refers to any communication wire, cable,
fiber, line, conduit, passage, or pathway operable to carry or
communicate information or data in any appropriate format. In an
embodiment, 'communication link,' as used herein this document,
may refer to logical communication channels that operate over
physical links, for example control links, software channels, and the
like. Unless stated otherwise, 'link,' 'communication link' and
'plurality of communication links," and the like, refer to the logical
channels operated by software and not to the physical link itself. In
an embodiment, a communication link has a corresponding physical
link.
[0014] FIG. 1 representatively illustrates a simplified block diagram of a
communication system 100 in accordance with an exemplary
embodiment of the present invention. Communication system 100
may include a plurality of cell sites 108, a plurality of mobile stations
102, a central office site 110, a plurality of base transceiver stations
104, a plurality of cell site elements 106, and a network
management system 116. Additionally, communication system 100
may include one or more aggregation nodes 112, a plurality of base
station controllers 114, a mobile switching center 118 coupled a
public switched telephone network (PSTN) and/or a packet
switched network such as an Internet Protocol (IP) network, and the
like.
5

[0015] Communication system 100 may be configured to represent a 2.5G
architecture applicable to a Global System for Mobile (GSM)
environment in accordance with a particular embodiment of the
present invention. In another embodiment, a 2.5G architecture is
offered for purposes of example and may alternatively be
substituted with any suitable networking system or arrangement
that provides a communicative platform for communication system
100. For example, the present invention may be used in
conjunction with a first generation or 3G network, where first
generation or 3G equivalent networking equipment is provided in
the architecture. Communication system 100 may be used in a
host of communication environments such as in conjunction with
any time division multiple access (TDMA) element, code division
multiple access (CDMA) element or protocol for example, whereby
signals from end users, subscriber units, or mobile stations 102
may be multiplexed.
[0016] In an embodiment, communication system 100 may operate to
monitor a group of physical links and/or their corresponding
communication links that may distribute traffic as a collective entity.
Communication system 100 may further provide an alert signal to a
suitable next destination (e.g. a network manager or system
administrator) when configurable tolerances of noise occur or
subside on a given physical link and/or communication link that is
being monitored. Communication system 100 may further provide
6

an alert message to a network manager or system operator that
warns of the error condition. The network manager or system
administrator may respond to the alert message by simply noting
the condition, or by removing or restoring one or more noisy
communication links from/to traffic scheduling when configurable
tolerances of noise occur/subside. In order to make such traffic
management determinations, communication system 100 may use
current traffic utilization characteristics associated with the physical
links and/or communication links and/or activity parameters
associated with the links in order to assist in making link removal,
restoration, or modification decisions.
[0017] In an embodiment, where only a single communication link
associated with a data exchange remains, communication system
100 may allow the final link to be left operational. Notifications of
link additions/removals may be directed to nodes that may then
adjust the total throughput (i.e. reduce the allowed number of voice,
video, or data calls, redistribute information to other web servers or
other links to handle transactions, etc.) across the network. In
another embodiment, where only a single communication link
remains, communication system 100 may remove the final
communication link. Removing the final link may force all new
bearer traffic to another BTS or mobile station for better "quality"
instead of allow traffic, even with less throughput to suffer degraded
performance.
7

[0018] Mobile station 102 may be an entity, such as a client, subscriber,
end user, or customer that seeks to initiate a communication
session or data exchange in communication system 100 via any
suitable network. Mobile station 102 may operate to use any
suitable device for communications in communication system 100.
Mobile station 102 may further represent a communications
interface for an end user of communication system 100. Mobile
station 102 may be a cellular or other wireless telephone, an
electronic notebook, a computer, a personal digital assistant (PDA),
or any other device, component, or object capable of initiating a
data exchange facilitated by communication system 100. Mobile
station 102 may also be inclusive of any suitable interface to the
human user or to a computer, such as a display, microphone,
keyboard, or other terminal equipment. Mobile station 102 may
alternatively be any device or object that seeks to initiate a
communication on behalf of another entity or element, such as a
program, a database, or any other component, device, element, or
object capable of initiating a voice or a data exchange within
communication system 100.
[0019] Base transceiver stations 104 are communicative interfaces that
may comprise radio transmission/reception devices, components,
or objects, and antennas. Base transceiver stations 104 may be
coupled to any communications device or element, such as mobile
station 102 for example. Base transceiver stations 104 may also be
8

coupled to base station controllers 114 (via one or more
intermediate elements) that use a landline (such as a T1/E1 line,
Ethernet, OCn fiberoptic, and the like) interface. A non-limiting
example of this may be backhaul communication link 120. In
another embodiment, base transceiver stations 104 may operate as
a series of complex radio modems where appropriate. Base
transceiver stations 104 may also perform transcoding and rate
adaptation functions in accordance with particular needs.
[0020] In operation, communication system 100 may include multiple cell
sites 108 that communicate with mobile stations 102 using base
transceiver stations 104 and cell site element 106. Central office
site 110 may use aggregation node 112 and base station controllers
114 for communicating with cell site 108. One or more network
management systems 116 may be coupled to either cell site 108
and central office site 110 (or both as desired), whereby mobile
switching center 118 provides an interface between base station
controllers 114 (of central office site 110) and PSTN, packet
switched network, and/or any other suitable communication
network. Base transceiver stations 104 may be coupled to cell site
element 106 by an Ethernet link or any other suitable
communication link or element operable to facilitate data
exchanges. A backhaul communication link 120 between cell site
element 106 and aggregation node 112 (or between BTS 104 and
9

aggregation node 112) may also include a suitable physical link
(e.g. T1/E1 line, T3/E3 line, OCn fiberoptic, and the like).
[0021] Base station controllers 114 may operate as management
components for a radio interface. This may be done through
remote commands to a corresponding base transceiver station (e.g.
base transceiver station 104) within communication system 100.
One base station controller 114 may manage more than one base
transceiver station 104. Some of the responsibilities of base station
controllers 114 may include management of radio channels and
assisting in handover scenarios.
[0022] In operation, layer two based traffic may be communicated by each
base transceiver station 104 (using a logical channel, i.e.
communication link, over a physical link) to cell site element 106 of
cell site 108. Cell site element 106 may multiplex payloads together
from the layer two based traffic that have a common destination.
This may be done, for example and without limitation, using one or
more Digital Access Cross-connect Switches (DACS). The
multiplexed payloads as well as any payloads extracted from the
network management system (e.g. IP or Ethernet traffic) may be
communicated across a communication link to aggregation node
112 within central office site 110. Aggregation node 112 may also
include a DACS to demultiplex the payloads for delivery to an
appropriate base station controller 114 or network management
10

system 116 and to translate from one physical link to another (i.e.
from T1 to OCn or T3, and the like).
[0023] Mobile switching center 118 may operate as an interface between
PSTN and base station controllers 114, and potentially between
multiple other mobile switching centers in a network and base
station controller 114. Mobile switching center 118 represents a
location that generally houses communication switches and
computers and ensures that its cell sites in a given geographical
area are properly connected. Cell sites refer generally to the
transmission and reception equipment or components that connect
elements such as mobile station 102 to a network. By controlling
transmission power and radio frequencies, mobile switching center
118 may monitor the movement and the transfer of a wireless
communication from one cell to another cell and from one
frequency or channel to another frequency or channel. In a given
communication environment, communication system 100 may
include multiple mobile switching centers 118 that are operable to
facilitate communications between base station controllers 114 and
PSTN. Mobile switching center 118 may also generally handle
connection, tracking, status, billing information, and other user
information for communications in a designated area where
appropriate.
[0024] PSTN represents a worldwide telephone system that is operable to
conduct or facilitate communications. PSTN may be any land line
it

telephone network operable to facilitate communications between
two entities, such as two persons, a person and a computer, two
computers, or in any other environment in which data is exchanged
for purposes of communication. According to one embodiment of
the present invention, PSTN may operate in a wireless domain,
facilitating data exchanges between mobile station 102 and any
other suitable entity within or external to communication system
100.
[0025] Packet switched network may be a series of points or nodes of
interconnected communication paths for receiving and transmitting
packets of information that propagate through communication
system 100. Packet switched network offers a communications
interface between mobile stations 102 and any other suitable
network equipment. Packet switched network may be any local
area network (LAN), metropolitan area network (MAN), wide area
network (WAN), wireless local area network (WLAN), virtual private
network (VPN), or any other appropriate architecture or system that
facilitates communications in a network environment. Packet
switched network implements a transmission control
protocol/internet protocol (TCP/IP) communication language
protocol in a particular embodiment of the present invention.
However, packet switched network may alternatively implement any
other suitable communications protocol (e.g. frame relay, X.25,
12

asynchronous transfer mode (ATM), etc.) for transmitting and
receiving data packets within communication system 100.
[0026] Aggregation node 112 and cell site element 106 are network
elements that may share one or more of the same functionalities
and/or capabilities. For purposes of example and teaching only, a
noise monitoring module 115 may be described as being positioned
in at least one of aggregation node 112 and/or cell site element
106. In another embodiment, noise monitoring module 115 may be
distributed between cell site element 106 and aggregation node
112. In yet another embodiment, noise monitoring module 115 may
be integrated with BTS 104, where BTS 104 does not include a
separate cell site element. In this embodiment, the features of cell
site 108 and cell site element 106 may be integrated with BTS 104.
[0027] Alternatively, such a capability may be provided in any other
suitable location of communication system 100 or provided
separately as its own distinct structure, device, component, module,
element or object. It is also critical to note that the use of the terms
'aggregation node' and 'cell site element' herein in this document
only connotes an example representation of one or more elements
associated with base transceiver station 104 and base station
controller 114. These terms have been chosen arbitrarily and
offered for purposes of teaching only and do not necessarily imply
any particular architecture or configuration. Moreover, the terms
cell site element' and 'aggregation node' are intended to
13

encompass any network element operable to facilitate a data
exchange in a network environment. Accordingly, cell site element
106 and aggregation node 112 may be routers, switches, bridges,
gateways, load-balancers, interfaces, or any other suitable module,
device, component, element or object operable to effectuate one or
more of the operations, tasks, or functionalities associated with
monitoring noise data as implied, described, provided, or offered
herein.
[0028] In an embodiment, noise monitoring module 115 in cell site element
106 and/or aggregation node 112 or BTS 104 may monitor an
element (e.g. a controller chip) that controls the backhaul
communication link 120. Cell site element 106 and/or aggregation
node 112 may monitor various errors being reported there and, in a
particular embodiment, monitor line code violations, path code
violations, bi-polar violations, or excessive zeros that occur.
Alternatively, cell site element 106 and/or aggregation node 112 or
BTS 104 may monitor any other suitable errors or noise parameters
in accordance with particular needs (link alarms or higher level
application indicators such as dropped packets, retransmission
requests, and the like). When the physical link and/or the
communication link becomes noisy, a warning signal may be
communicated over the communication link to an administrator or a
network operator such that he is made aware of the possible
deterioration in quality of data. The alert signal may also be
14

communicated to an administration module (that may be provided in
any suitable location within communication system 100) that reports
or consolidates such information to be reviewed by an
administrator, network operator, or any other suitable entity.
Considerable flexibility is provided to an end user or network
administrator in configuring any number of parameters that result in
a notification or removal operation being implemented. For
example, a network administrator may configure a given time
interval where the number of errors is being detected. Additionally,
a network administrator or system operator may decide to set a
parameter based on a percentage of information or data being
received. Considerable versatility and flexibility is granted by the
architecture of the present invention in that any noise criteria (e.g.
noise data associated with time, percentage error, error number,
throughput, etc.) may be implemented by communication system
100.
[0029] At cell site element 106 and/or aggregation node 112 or BTS 104,
an alert notification may be generated that indicates a particular
severity in noise associated with a physical link or error associated
with a communication link. The alert notification (via a configuration
command) may be converted into an appropriate signal to be sent
via a simple network management protocol (SNMP) to a suitable
application that may consolidate monitoring functions of a network.
Alternatively, this signal or notification may be sent to any suitable
15

entity, module, element, or object operable to authorize or
otherwise control managerial functions or administration parameters
associated with a network or a communication link. A
corresponding element may, in turn, filter elements (as it may be
configured to do) or pass the alert notification up to a higher level of
management. Additionally, the alert notification may trigger a
suitable protocol for networking equipment or gear to execute some
action based on the signal. Such alert notifications may be passed
on to suitable maintenance, control, and fault mechanisms that
identify and process the signal such that the error condition or noise
parameter may be addressed. The alert notification may also flag
the logging of error messages to a console or controller. The
protocol may be applicable to any type of layer one medium that
allows for the gathering or reporting of physical layer statistics
associated with error conditions or noise. For cyclic redundancy
check (CRC) errors, a path code violation counter may be
incremented. One or more counters may be provided to cell site
element 106 and/or aggregation node 112 in order to achieve this
operation.
[0030] In operation of an example embodiment, a method for detecting
errors may be effectuated by monitoring noise at the physical layer
of each network interface and/or error over the corresponding
communication link. This can be achieved, for example, by
monitorina the bit errors rates and network CRC errors.
16

Communication system 100 provides considerable flexibility in that
noise tolerance levels can be configured based on any number of
parameters, such as layer one error threshold including a number of
errors per sample period, sample period, number of samples, or
percent of errored samples for example.
[0031] A periodic timer included within cell site element 106 and/or
aggregation node 112 or BTS 104 (or provided at any other suitable
location) may monitor the physical layer according to the current
settings or designations associated with error tolerances and initiate
the appropriate action when tolerances are exceeded (e.g. cause
alert notifications, notify a higher layer of actions that were [or that
should be] taken, etc.). A higher layer timer monitor element may
also be provided to monitor the number of links and network
utilization, and to adjust the tolerances of the links, as needed,
based on current system conditions or particular networking needs.
[0032] Such a configuration allows noise associated with multiple network
links to be managed collectively as a group, rather than as separate
entities. In another embodiment, individual communication links
may be managed individually within bundle of communication links.
The architecture of communication system 100 may further allow
tolerable loss to be designated or otherwise selected based on the
particular customer's network environment, system performance
characteristics, or particular data transmission needs. For example,
the integrity of real-time voice data requires more sensitive (i.e.
17

lower threshold) system configuration as compared to higher
thresholds associated with simple data traffic.
[0033] Cell site element 106 and/or aggregation node 112 or BTS 104 may
include a noise monitoring module 115, in accordance with one
embodiment of the present invention that implements one or more
noise monitoring tasks as described herein. Noise monitoring
module 115 may include any suitable hardware, software,
algorithms, objects, or elements operable to facilitate the
functionality or operations thereof.
[0034] Noise monitoring module 115 may monitor the link quality of
individual communication links (i.e. logical links) within a multilink
bundle, for example and without limitation backhaul communication
link 120. Noise monitoring module 115 may provide the ability to
issue a warning or an alert on reaching a certain level of noise, and
further remove the communication link based on a second level of
noise. Conversely, once the level of noise improves to a certain
level of quality, the communication link may be restored to service,
which may be accompanied by an indication of improved
communication quality to be communicated to any appropriate
source or location.
[0035] In an example embodiment, noise monitoring module 115 may
include two monitoring aspects. The first is a link warning element
that may include a monitor that provides the capability to issue a
warning when the communication link surpasses a configured level
18

of noise. A notification may then be given when the link noise level
improves to a second configured level of noise. The second is a
link removal element that may include a monitor that provides the
capability to remove a communication link from service in the
bundle and, further, to issue an error when the communication link
surpasses a configured level of noise. The communication link may
be restored and a notice issued when the link noise level improves
below a second configured level of noise. Both warning and
removal types of monitors may include two thresholds and/or
durations. The first threshold and duration may operate to cause
the error condition. The second threshold and duration may
operate to clear the error condition.
[0036] When only one active communication link remains in the multilink
bundle, an optional attempt may be made to maintain this
communication link in service by issuing an alert rather than
removing the communication link from service when the link
removal level of noise is reached. The T1 standard error rate may
be in effect, where appropriate, in order to remove the final link from
service. In another embodiment, the last communication link in a
multilink bundle may be removed with traffic being redirected to
another BTS 104. For example and without limitation, the last
communication link in the multilink bundle may dropped with the
traffic data being directed to an available BTS 104 having a higher
or highest quality signal (low BER, and the like).
19

[0037] In general, noisy communication links may be removed based on
the Bit Error Ratio (BER) of individual or multiple physical links.
Such a BER may be reflected by Line Code Violation (LCV) or Path
Code Violation (PCV) errors. An LCV is an occurrence of either a
Bi-Polar Violation (BPV) or an Excessive Zeroes (EXZ) Error.
Additionally, noise monitoring module 115 may implement or
involve any other suitable violation or error condition or
characteristic. In an embodiment, BER in one or both directions
over physical link may be monitored for exceeding the various noise
thresholds.
[0038] Two options may be included within noise monitoring module 115,
one for link warning and one for link removal operations. These two
options may also be configured independently of each other where
appropriate. Either or both may be used in a configuration in
accordance with particular needs. Each option may be entered in
two forms: the error condition and the clear condition.
[0039] Both the warning and the removal conditions may cause a
notification to be generated upon the threshold being exceeded for
the sample duration. In addition, notification messages may be
generated when their clear thresholds are reached for the clear
sample duration. For the removal/restore conditions, if it is the last
communication link in a multilink bundle, different remove
notifications and severities may be presented in order to indicate
the thresholds were surpassed, but no removal/restore occurred,
20

Once a warn or remove noise level has been exceeded, and the
associated notification generated, the notification may not occur
again until its corresponding clear level has been reached and the
clear notification is issued. The notification may be marked with a
timestamp provided by any suitable protocol such as an input
output supervision (IOS) protocol for example.
[0040] FIG.'s 2A and 2B representatively illustrate a flow diagram with
exemplary steps associated with a method of the invention in
accordance with an exemplary embodiment of the present
invention. In step 202, at least one of a plurality of physical links
and a plurality of communication links are monitored that are
associated with a plurality of data communications. The plurality of
communication links may correspond to the plurality of physical
links. These may be, for example and without limitation, a plurality
of physical links and communication links making up a bundle of
backhaul communication links 120. In step 206, it is determined if a
first time interval has elapsed. If not, monitoring of the plurality of
physical links and/or communication links continues. If so, a
statistical quantity of a noise element is calculated for a selected
one or more of at least one of the plurality of physical links or the
plurality of communication links in step 208. For example, in an
embodiment, a statistical quantity may be calculated for each
communication link in a multilink bundle.
21

[0041] In an embodiment, noise element can be the BER or any parameter
discussed above used to derive BER. In another embodiment,
noise element may be a time interval associated with one or more
of the plurality of physical links. In yet another embodiment, noise
element may be a percentage of errors or a number of errors
associated with one or more of plurality of physical links or the
plurality of communication links.
[0042] First time interval may be any interval set by a system
administrator, user, and the like, for example and without limitation
thirty minutes, and the like. In an embodiment, plurality of physical
links and/or the plurality of communication links are monitored with
the statistical quantity calculated using data gathered over first time
interval. In an embodiment, statistical quantity may be a standard
deviation of noise element as measured on selected one or more of
at least one of the plurality of physical links or the plurality of
communication links. In an embodiment, standard deviation may
be one, two or more standard deviations of noise element as
needed for any particular system architecture or monitoring criteria.
[0043] In an embodiment, in step 206, statistical quantity is updated by
averaging with a statistical quantity calculated over a previous first
time interval. For example, the standard deviation of noise element
as measured over one of first time interval may be averaged with
the standard deviation of noise element measured over a previous
first time interval. In another embodiment, the standard deviation of
22

noise element as measured over one of first time interval may be
averaged with one or more standard deviations as measured over
multiple previous first time intervals respectively. In yet another
embodiment, statistical quantity may include a weighted average of
each of a standard deviation of noise element at two or more of first
time intervals respectively.
[0044] In step 210, noise element is measured at a second time interval.
Second time interval may be any interval set by a system
administrator, user, and the like, for example and without limitation,
ten seconds. In step 212, a first noise threshold is calculated based
on a user threshold and the statistical quantity calculated above. In
an embodiment, user threshold may be a threshold of noise
element set by a user or system administrator, which may represent
a level where noise element is deemed to unacceptably interfere
with one or more of plurality of communication links.
[0045] In an embodiment of step 212, first noise threshold may be
calculated by subtracting statistical quantity from user threshold. In
one embodiment, first noise threshold may be a user threshold
minus a standard deviation of noise element (or an average or
weighted average of standard deviations as described above). It is
clear that unlike the prior art, first noise threshold is not fixed, but
changes depending on statistical quantity. Further, first noise
threshold may be updated and changed based on a more
reDresentative samole of noise element that is beina encountered in
23

selected one or more of plurality of communication links. This is
because first noise threshold is a function of a standard deviation of
noise element actually measured over one or more communication
links.
[0046] In step 214 it is determined if noise element measured at second
time interval has exceeded first noise threshold calculated in step
212. If not, statistical quantity continues to update as described
above and noise element is continually measured at second time
interval as per the return arrow. If noise element does exceed first
noise threshold, then an alert notification is communicated by noise
monitoring module per step 216. In an embodiment, alert
notification may be communicated to network management system,
mobile switching center, a system administrator, and the like, as
described above.
[0047] In step 218 it is determined if noise element as measured at second
time interval has dropped below first noise threshold. If so, a stable
traffic pattern notification may be communicated to network
management system, mobile switching center, a system
administrator, and the like per step 220. If not, in an embodiment of
step 221, second noise threshold may be calculated by subtracting
statistical quantity from a second user threshold. In one
embodiment, second noise threshold may be a second user
threshold minus a standard deviation of noise element (or an
average or weiqhted average of standard deviations as described
24

above). It is clear that unlike the prior art, second noise threshold is
not fixed, but changes depending on statistical quantity. Further,
second noise threshold may be updated and change based on a
more representative sample of noise element that is being
encountered in selected one or more of plurality of communication
links. This is because second noise threshold is a function of a
standard deviation of noise element actually measured over one or
more communication links.
[0048] In step 222 it is determined if noise element has exceeded second
noise threshold. In an embodiment, second noise threshold may be
calculated by subtracting statistical quantity from a second user
threshold. In one embodiment, second noise threshold may be a
second user threshold minus a standard deviation of noise element.
Analogous to user threshold above, second user threshold may be
a threshold of noise element set by a user or system administrator,
which may represent a level where noise element is deemed to
unacceptably interfere with one or more of plurality of
communication links such that the one or more of the plurality of
communication links affected must be removed from service.
[0049] If noise element has not exceeded second noise threshold in step
222, then the monitoring of noise element continues per the return
arrow. If noise element has exceeded second noise threshold in
step 222, then it is determined if the affected link is the last link in a
multi-link bundle in step 224. If so, in optional step 226, the last link
25

is not removed from service per step 226. Step 226 may be
optional depending on the preferences of a system administrator as
to whether it is best to preserve the last communication link or to
transfer traffic to different BTS. If the affected link is not the last
link, then it is removed from service and a second alert notification
may be communicated to network management system, mobile
switching center, a system administrator, and the like, notifying of
the removal of the affected one or more communication links per
step 228.
[0050] In step 230, it is determined if noise element has dropped below
second noise threshold. If not, monitoring is continued per the
return arrow. If so, the one or more affected communication links
previously removed from service are restored and a restoration alert
notification may be communicated to network management system,
mobile switching center, a system administrator, and the like, per
step 232.
[0051] Some of the steps illustrated in FIG.2 may be changed or deleted
where appropriate and additional steps may also be added to the
flowchart. These changes may be based on specific
communication system architectures or particular networking
arrangements or configurations and do not depart from the scope or
the teachings of the present invention.
[0052] In addition, although the preceding description offers a noise
monitorina module to be implemented with particular devices (e.a
26

aggregation node 112 or cell site element 106), the noise
monitoring module provided may be embodied in a fabricated
module that is designed specifically for effectuating the monitoring
techniques as provided above. Moreover, such a module may be
compatible with any appropriate protocol and communication links
other than T1/E1 links, which were offered for purposes of teaching
and example only.
[0053] Additionally, although some example embodiments provided above
may reference voice data, communication system 100 may
cooperate with any other type of data in which monitoring protocols
are applicable. For example, normative or standard data, video
data, and audio-visual data may benefit from the teachings of the
present invention. Communication system 100 is adaptable in that it
may be used in conjunction with any information that is sought to be
compressed in a communications environment.
[0054] In the foregoing specification, the invention has been described with
reference to specific exemplary embodiments; however, it will be
appreciated that various modifications and changes may be made
without departing from the scope of the present invention as set
forth in the claims below. The specification and figures are to be
regarded in an illustrative manner, rather than a restrictive one and
all such modifications are intended to be included within the scope
of the present invention. Accordingly, the scope of the invention
should be determined bv the claims appended hereto and their
27

legal equivalents rather than by merely the examples described
above.
[0055] For example, the steps recited in any method or process claims
may be executed in any order and are not limited to the specific
order presented in the claims. Additionally, the components and/or
elements recited in any apparatus claims may be assembled or
otherwise operationally configured in a variety of permutations to
produce substantially the same result as the present invention and
are accordingly not limited to the specific configuration recited in the
claims.
[0056] Benefits, other advantages and solutions to problems have been
described above with regard to particular embodiments; however,
any benefit, advantage, solution to problem or any element that
may cause any particular benefit, advantage or solution to occur or
to become more pronounced are not to be construed as critical,
required or essential features or components of any or all the
claims.
[0057] As used herein, the terms "comprise", "comprises", "comprising",
"having", "including", "includes" or any variation thereof, are
intended to reference a non-exclusive inclusion, such that a
process, method, article, composition or apparatus that comprises a
list of elements does not include only those elements recited, but
may also include other elements not expressly listed or inherent to
such Drocess. method, article, comoosition or aDoaratus. Other
28

combinations and/or modifications of the above-described
structures, arrangements, applications, proportions, elements,
materials or components used in the practice of the present
invention, in addition to those not specifically recited, may be varied
or otherwise particularly adapted to specific environments,
manufacturing specifications, design parameters or other operating
requirements without departing from the general principles of the
same.
29

CLAIMS
We claim:
1. A method of managing a communication link, comprising:
monitoring at least one of a plurality of physical links and a
plurality of communication links associated with a plurality of data
communications, wherein the plurality of communication links
correspond to the plurality of physical links;
calculating a statistical quantity of a noise element of a
selected one or more of at least one of the plurality of physical links
and the plurality of communication links at a plurality of first time
intervals;
measuring the noise element of the selected one or more of
at least one of the plurality of physical links and the plurality of
communication links at a second time interval;
determining whether the noise element measured at the
second time interval has exceeded a first noise threshold; and
communicating an alert notification when the first noise
threshold is exceeded.
2. The method of claim 1, wherein the statistical quantity
comprises a standard deviation of the noise element.
30

3. The method of claim 1, wherein the statistical quantity
comprises one of an average and a weighted average of each of a
standard deviation of the noise element calculated at two or more of
the plurality of first time intervals.
4. The method of claim 1, wherein the first noise threshold
comprises a user threshold minus the statistical quantity.
5. The method of claim 1, wherein the noise element is
selected from a group consisting of:
a time interval associated with one or more of at least one of
the plurality of physical links and the plurality of communication
links;
an amount of errors associated with one or more of at least
one of the plurality of physical links and of the plurality of
communication links;
a percentage of errors associated with one or more of at
least one of the plurality of physical links and of the plurality of
communication links; and
a number of errors associated with one or more of at least
one of the plurality of physical links and of the plurality of
communication links.
6. The method of claim 1, further comprising.:
31

determining if the noise element measured at the second
time interval has exceeded a second noise threshold; and
if so, removing one or more of the plurality of communication
links associated with exceeding the second noise threshold, and
communicating a second alert notification.
7. The method of claim 6, wherein if a communication link
associated with exceeding the second noise threshold is a last link
in a multi-link bundle, it is not removed.
8. The method of claim 6, further comprising, restoring the
one or more of the plurality of communication links associated with
exceeding the second noise threshold when the noise element
drops below the second noise threshold and communicating a
restoration alert notification.
9. The method of claim 1, further comprising:
determining if the noise element has dropped below the first
noise threshold; and
if so, communicating a stable traffic pattern notification.
10. An apparatus for managing a communication link,
comprising:
32

at least one of a cell site, a base transceiver station and an
aggregation node operable to communicate data;
a noise monitoring module included with the at least one cell
site, base transceiver station and aggregation node, wherein the
noise monitoring module is operable to monitor at least one of a
plurality of physical links and a plurality of communication links
associated with a plurality of data communications, wherein the
plurality of communication links correspond to the plurality of
physical links, and execute a link analysis comprising:
calculating a statistical quantity of a noise element of a
selected one or more of at least one of the plurality of physical
links and the plurality of communication links at a plurality of first
time intervals;
measuring the noise element of the selected one or more
of at least one of the plurality of physical links and the plurality of
communication links at a second time interval;
determining whether the noise element measured at the
second time interval has exceeded a first noise threshold; and
communicating an alert notification when the first noise
threshold is exceeded.
33

A method
and apparatus of managing a
communication link may include
monitoring at least one of a
plurality of physical links and
a plurality of communication
links associated with a plurality of
data communications, calculating
a statistical quantity of a noise
element of a selected one or more
of at least one of the plurality of
physical links and the plurality
of communication links at a
plurality of first time intervals,
measuring the noise clement
of the selected one or more of
at least one of the plurality of
physical links and the plurality of
communication links at a second
time interval, determining whether
the noise element measured at
the second time interval has
exceeded a first noise threshold,
and communicating an alert
notification when the first noise
threshold is exceeded.

Documents:

00684-kolnp-2008-abstract.pdf

00684-kolnp-2008-claims.pdf

00684-kolnp-2008-correspondence others.pdf

00684-kolnp-2008-description complete.pdf

00684-kolnp-2008-drawings.pdf

00684-kolnp-2008-form 1.pdf

00684-kolnp-2008-form 3.pdf

00684-kolnp-2008-form 5.pdf

00684-kolnp-2008-gpa.pdf

00684-kolnp-2008-international publication.pdf

00684-kolnp-2008-international search report.pdf

00684-kolnp-2008-pct priority document notification.pdf

00684-kolnp-2008-pct request form.pdf

684-KOLNP-2008-(11-08-2014)-CORRESPONDENCE.pdf

684-KOLNP-2008-(11-08-2014)-OTHERS.pdf

684-KOLNP-2008-(16-01-2012)-ASSIGNMENT.pdf

684-KOLNP-2008-(16-01-2012)-CORRESPONDENCE.pdf

684-KOLNP-2008-(16-01-2012)-FORM 1.pdf

684-KOLNP-2008-(16-01-2012)-FORM 2.pdf

684-KOLNP-2008-(16-01-2012)-FORM 3.pdf

684-KOLNP-2008-(16-01-2012)-FORM 5.pdf

684-KOLNP-2008-(16-01-2012)-FORM 6.pdf

684-KOLNP-2008-(16-01-2012)-PA.pdf

684-KOLNP-2008-(16-07-2014)-ANNEXURE TO FORM 3.pdf

684-KOLNP-2008-(16-07-2014)-CLAIMS.pdf

684-KOLNP-2008-(16-07-2014)-CORRESPONDENCE.pdf

684-KOLNP-2008-(16-07-2014)-DRAWINGS.pdf

684-KOLNP-2008-(16-07-2014)-FORM-2.pdf

684-KOLNP-2008-(16-07-2014)-OTHERS.pdf

684-KOLNP-2008-(16-07-2014)-PA.pdf

684-KOLNP-2008-(16-07-2014)-PETITION UNDER RULE 137-1.pdf

684-KOLNP-2008-(16-07-2014)-PETITION UNDER RULE 137.pdf

684-KOLNP-2008-ASSIGNMENT.pdf

684-KOLNP-2008-CORRESPONDENCE OTHERS 1.1.pdf

684-kolnp-2008-form 18.pdf

abstract-00684-kolnp-2008.jpg


Patent Number 263890
Indian Patent Application Number 684/KOLNP/2008
PG Journal Number 48/2014
Publication Date 28-Nov-2014
Grant Date 26-Nov-2014
Date of Filing 15-Feb-2008
Name of Patentee MOTOROLA, INC.
Applicant Address 1303 EAST ALGONQUIN ROAD, SCHAUMBURG, ILLINOIS
Inventors:
# Inventor's Name Inventor's Address
1 BORNEMAN JEFFREY L 22W071 STRATFORD COURT , GLEN ELLYN, ILLINOIS 60137
2 KUNWER MOID M 5415 GABLE MEADOWS DRIVE , SUGARLAND, TEXAS 77479
3 GANESAN ESHWAR PRASAD 732 LAKE VIEW DRIVE, APT. 2D , WHEELING, ILLINOIS 60090
4 RANGANATHAN MURALI 16633 SOUTH 27TH LANE , PHOENIX, ARIZONA 85045
PCT International Classification Number G01R 31/08
PCT International Application Number PCT/US2006/016561
PCT International Filing date 2006-05-01
PCT Conventions:
# PCT Application Number Date of Convention Priority Country
1 11/210031 2005-08-22 U.S.A.