Title of Invention

CREEP-RESISTANT FERRITIC STEEL

Abstract The invention relates to a ferritic steel that is particularly creep-resistant at temperatures from 600 to 1000°C and contains precipitations of an intermetallic phase Fe2 (M, Si) and/or Fe7 (M, Si), where M is a metal, in particular niobium, molybdenum, tungsten and/or tantalum. The precipitations may be formed during its production, during a heat treatment or during use at high temperature. The metal is partially substituted by silicon. As a result, it is possible to introduce considerably more creep-resistance enhancing precipitations into the steel than on the basis of the prior art, without thereby impairing the oxidation resistance of the material. If the alloy additionally contains chromium, the steel can be made into a chromium-oxide forming steel, which can be used inter alia for the bipolar plate in a stack of high-temperature fuel cells. The bipolar plate can be designed in such a way that its oxidic surface layer has good electrical conductivity and low chromium evaporation.
Full Text Description
CREEP-RESISTANT FERRITIC STEEL
The invention relates to a creep-resistant ferritic steel for components subject to high
temperatures, and particularly for use in high-temperature fuel cells.
STATE OF THE ART
A high-temperature fuel cell (solid oxide fuel cell, SOFC) converts the chemical energy of a fuel,
such as hydrogen, methane, or carbon monoxide, directly into electric energy by using an
oxidant, such as oxygen or air. The fuel is separated from the oxidant by a solid electrolyte,
such as yttrium-stabilized zirconium oxide. At a cell operating temperature of between 600 and
1000°C, the solid electrolyte conducts oxygen ions from the oxygen side (cathode region) to the
fuel side (anode region), where they react with the fuel. In the process, electrons are released,
which can supply an external load.
The solid electrolyte is coated with porous, catalytically active electrode materials. In general,
the anode on the fuel side is made of a cermet of metallic nickel and yttrium-stabilized zirconium
oxide. The cathode on the oxygen side is typically made of perovskite, based on lanthanum.

As an individual fuel cell only emits a low voltage in the range of 1 volt, and a plurality of fuel
cells must be interconnected for most technical applications. Typically, for this purpose a
plurality of cells are layered to form a so-called stack. To this end, a bipolar plate is required
between every two cells, which is also referred to as the interconnector. The bipolar plate
conducts the current from one cell to the neighboring cell and at the same time divides the
cathode region of one cell from the anode region of the other cell in a gastight manner. In most
SOFC flat cell designs under discussion today, the bipolar plate also assumes the function of
distributing the gas in the cells and provides the cells with mechanical stability (EP 0338 823
A1). For this reason, in contrast to the electrolyte and the electrodes, which are about 100 ^m
thick, the bipolar plate is typically several millimeters thick. In more recent SOFC designs,
particularly for mobile applications in vehicles or airplanes, however, the bipolar plates are
already configured considerably thinner (0.3 to 1 mm) for weight saving reasons.
The demands placed on a bipolar plate are diverse. It must exhibit high oxidation resistance at
high temperatures, while fuel is applied on one side and oxygen on the other side. In addition, it
is mechanically firmly connected to the remaining components of the cell, some of which are
made of ceramics. In order to ensure that temperature fluctuations do not result in any
mechanical stress, which could destroy the remaining components, the coefficient of thermal
expansion (approx. 10 to 12*10-6 K-1) of the bipolar plate must be suited to the remaining
components. The exact value of the coefficient of expansion requires depends on the respective
cell design. Anode substrate supported cells typically require slightly higher coefficients of
expansion than ceil designs that are based on an electrolyte film design.
Ferritic chromium steels can generally satisfy this requirement profile. These materials form an
oxide layer based on Cr2O3 on the surface, the layer protecting the inside of the material from
corrosion. However, these layers are typically unstable at the high operating temperatures of
high-temperature fuel cells. They flake and as a result the fragments can clog the gas ducts of
the bipolar plate and impair gas flow. Furthermore, over time they grow thicker due to further
corrosion, which increasingly reduces electrical conductivity and therefore the power output of
the fuel cell stack. In addition, if a high oxygen supply is present, as is the case in the cathode
region, volatile chromium oxides or chromium hydroxides are formed, which act as a catalyst
poison on the cathode, or on the interface between the cathode and the electrolyte, and thereby
further permanently reduce the cell power.
For the stabilization of the chromium oxide layers, DE 44 10 711 C1 discloses a bipolar plate

made of a chromium oxide-forming alloy, the plate being provided with a protective coating
made of aluminum in the region of the gas-conducting surfaces. At the operating temperature,
the aluminum layer on the surface thereof forms an AI2O3 layer, which protects the chromium
oxide layer from corrosion. The disadvantageous decrease in electrical conductivity due to the
chromium oxide layers in the region of the contact surfaces between the electrodes and bipolar
plate, however, is something that still must be accepted.
Furthermore, a component for conducting current for high-temperature fuel cells is known from
EP 04 10 166 A1. This component comprises a non-oxidizable metallic casing made of gold,
palladium, or platinum, which has high electrical conductivity and does not lose any material due
to evaporation. However, such a component is very expensive to produce, and the stability
thereof during long-term operation is not assured.
DE 44 22 624 A1 describes a method for protecting chromium-containing bodies, wherein a
protective coating made of oxidic chromate is applied. A disadvantage of these coating methods,
however, is that they make the bipolar plates considerably more expensive. In addition, the
layers have no self-healing capability during operation if they are mechanically damaged.
DE 100 25 108 A1 discloses new compositions forferritic interconnector materials. Through a
special combination of alloying elements, it was possible to form oxide layers on steel surfaces
at conventional operating temperatures, the layers having a low growth rate, excellent adhesion
to the metal substrate, high electrical conductivity and low chromium evaporation. In order to
achieve this combination of advantageous properties, for example, the maximum concentrations
of the alloying elements of aluminum and silicon were limited to very low values. Since these
elements are frequently added as deoxidants during conventional steel production, the
advantageous steel properties can often only be achieved by using novel, complex and
therefore expensive production methods.
Particularly in the case of stacking designs that provide for only low interconnector thicknesses
(such as 0.3-1 mm), high operating temperatures (above about 800°C) and frequent
temperature changes (such as several hundred, or even several thousand, temperature
changes during the operating time of the cell), one particular property of ferritic steels
disadvantageously stands out. At high temperatures, these steels have only low creep
resistance. Thus, when subject to mechanical stress caused, for example, by oxidation, there is
a tendency to permanent plastic deformation. As a result, the gastight seal between two fuel

cells achieved by the bipolar plate can break open and the entire fuel cell stack can fail.
Typically, in order to increase creep resistance, transition metals, refractory metals, or light
metals are added by way of alloying. The disadvantage is that transition metals frequently bring
about austenitizing of the material, which increases the coefficient of expansion and worsens
the oxidation resistance. In addition, refractory metals often reduce the ductility of the material.
Light metals typically worsen the protective properties and electrical conductivity of the Cr-
based oxidic cover layers, even if they are only present in very low concentrations of 0.1 to 0.4
weight percent. Steels made creep-resistant in this way are therefore not suited as materials for
producing the interconnector of a high-temperature fuel cell.
OBJECT AND SOLUTION
The object of the invention is therefore to provide a ferritic steel, which is suited as a production
material for the interconnector of a high-temperature fuel cell, and which exhibits better creep
resistance at temperatures above 600°C than the steels used according to the state of the art.
A further object of the invention is to provide a bipolar plate, which is lastingly gastight, even
with frequent temperature changes, and which is made of the ferritic steel mentioned above,
and a fuel cell stack with an improved service life at high temperatures and frequent
temperature changes.
These objects are achieved according to the invention by a steel according to the main claim
and by the use of the steel in a bipolar plate and in a fuel cell stack according to the
independent claims. Further advantageous embodiments will be apparent from the dependent
claims referring to these claims.
SUBJECT MATTER OF THE INVENTION
The ferritic steel comprises precipitations of an intermetallic phase of the Fe2(M, Si) or Fe7(M,
Si)6 type having at least one metal alloying element M. This intermetallic phase can be formed in
advance during production of the steel. However, it can also be formed following subsequent
heat treatment, or during subsequent use of the steel at temperatures between 600 and 1000°C.

In principle, any metal that, together with iron, forms an intermetallic phase of the Fe2M or Fe7M6
type, and particularly niobium, molybdenum, tungsten or tantalum, is suited as the alloying
element M. It is also possible to use a combination of a plurality of metals M.
It was found that the addition of such metals by alloying per se according to the state of the art
renders the steel unsuitable for use in a high-temperature fuel cell as a result of two physical
mechanisms of action that are independent from each other. Firstly, precipitations of the Fe2M
or Fe7M6 type have an extremely inadequate oxidation resistance. As a result, at high
temperatures quickly growing oxides form locally. Secondly, the element M present in the
alloying matrix is incorporated in the Cr oxide layer and thereby considerably increases the
growth rate.
According to the invention, the metal M is partially substituted by silicon in the intermetallic
phase. The intermetallic phase then has a general chemical formula of the Fe2(M, Si) type or
Fe7(M, Si)6 type. Surprisingly, it was found that, as a result, the oxidation resistance of the
intermetallic phases mentioned above is significantly increased at high temperatures,
particularly in contact with operating atmospheres of high-temperature fuel cells. At the same
time, disadvantageous integration of the metal M into the Cr oxide layer is suppressed.
It was also recognized that, in the substitution of the metal M, silicon usually does not bring
about the disadvantageous effect known from the state of the art for light-metal alloying
elements since the silicon is dissolved in the intermetallic phase. The disadvantageous effect
according to the state of the art was caused by the internal oxidation of the silicon at high
temperatures.
Internal oxidation shall be understood as the formation of oxide precipitations within the alloy,
beneath the oxidic, external cover layer on the alloy surface.
As a consequence of the internal oxidation process, metal inclusions developed in the
chromium oxide cover layer due to the volume increase, and partially continuous Si oxide layers
were formed beneath the chromium oxide. These disadvantageous effects of the silicon are
suppressed in the case of substitution of the metal M by silicon according to the invention, as
long as, at a maximum, only an amount of silicon is added that can still completely dissolve in
the intermetallic phase. The maximum effective ratio for the silicon and metal M depends both
on the selection of the metal M and the composition of the base material. For the specific
application, those skilled in the art will be able to determine this ratio without undue

experimentation.
Due to the substitution according to the invention of the metal M by silicon, for applications in
high-temperature fuel cells, with a view to higher creep resistance, it is possible to introduce
more precipitations of the Fe2(M, Si) or Fe7(M, Si)6 intermetallic phase in the ferritic alloying
matrix than was possible according to the state of the art with Fe2M or Fe7M6. These
precipitations significantly increase the creep resistance compared to an alloy that has no
precipitations of the Fe2(M, Si) or Fe7(M, Si)6 type.
As a typical example, ferritic steel having 22 wt% chromium and 0.4 wt% manganese shall be
mentioned here. At 700°C, this steel has a consistent creep of 1.5% under a load of 10 MPa
after 1000 hours. By adding elements M, such as niobium and/or tungsten, in an amount of only
1 wt% in combination with a silicon addition of 0.3 wt%, the permanent creep of the steel at the
same chromium and manganese contents decreases to 0.06%, which is to say by about a factor
of 25.
According to the state of the art, the maximum permitted content of precipitations of the Fe2M
type or Fe7M6 type was very limited. The inadequate oxidation resistance of the precipitations of
the Fe2M or Fe7M6 type meant that, when using the steel in the high-temperature fuel cell, very
rapidly growing oxide layers formed. This was disadvantageous particularly for chromium oxide-
forming steels because, locally, the formation of the protective Cr-based oxidic cover layers was
impaired, or the growth rate was accelerated. As a result, the material became less corrosion-
resistant overall. With regard to the content of Fe2M and/or Fe7M6 in the alloy, it was thus
always necessary to find a compromise between increasing the creep resistance and reducing
the oxidation resistance. The partial substitution, according to the invention, of the metal M by
silicon removes the restriction in the maximum possible creep resistance resulting from this
compromise.
Advantageously, the steel contains the metal M and silicon in such concentrations that an
intermetallic phase of the Fe2(M, Si) or Fe7(M, Si)6 type is able to form at temperatures between
700°C and 900°C. This temperature range corresponds to the target operating temperature of
modern high-temperature fuel cells and is therefore technologically particularly relevant. The
amount of metal M that is required will be apparent from known phase diagrams. For example,
in order to form a Fe2Nb phase in the temperature range of between 700 and 900°C, the alloy
requires a niobium content of at least approximately 0.2 wt%. In order to form the Fe2W phase

at 800°C, the alloy requires a tungsten content of at least approximately 3 wt%. If the metal M
and silicon are present in these advantageous concentrations, the intermetallic phase can be
formed at the time of the first use of the steel in a high-temperature fuel cell. However,
alternatively, it can also still be formed directly during the production of the steel.
The alloy should have precipitations of Fe2(M, Si) and/or Fe7(M, Si)6 in the amount of between 1
and 8 percent by volume, and preferably between 2.5 and 5 percent by volume. At percentages
below this range, the increase in creep resistance is technically insignificant. Percentages
above this range, however, regularly result in undesirable embrittlement of the alloy.
The sum of the precipitations of the Fe2(M, Si) phase and/or Fe7(M, Si)6 should range between 2
and 15 at% of silicon. At a silicon content of less than 2 at% in the Fe2(M, Si) and/or Fe7(M, Si)6
phase, the oxidation resistance of the intermetallic phase is inadequate. A silicon content above
15 at% exceeds the solubility limit of the silicon in the intermetallic phase, so that the known
disadvantages of silicon as an alloying element gradually begin to recur as the silicon oxidizes
internally. A silicon content in the advantageous range between 2 and 15 at% in the intermetallic
phase is achieved, for example when using niobium as the only metal M, with a mass ratio of
silicon to niobium of between 0.08 and 1, and more preferably between 0.1 and 0.4. In this way,
for example, in a ferritic steel with 22 wt% chromium and an addition of niobium and silicon of
0.6 or 0.25 wt% during use at 800°C, precipitations of the Fe2(Nb, Si) type form, having a silicon
percentage of about 7 at%. The sum of all precipitations results in a percentage of about 1 vol%
in the steel.
In combination with the above-described measures for increasing the creep resistance, the
advantageous measures described below can be used to achieve optimal suitability as a
production material for the interconnector of a high-temperature fuel cell, without compromising
the higher creep resistance achieved according to the invention.
Advantageously, the sum of the concentrations of nickel and cobalt in the alloy is greater than 0
but less than 4 wt%, and preferably less than 1 wt%. This prevents alloy transitioning into an
austenitic structure at high temperatures, as will, for example, occur predominantly in a high-
temperature fuel cell.
Advantageously, the concentrations of carbon, nitrogen, sulfur, boron and phosphorus in the
alloy each are greater than 0 but less than 0.1 wt%, and preferably less than 0.02 wt%. These
elements are accompanying elements and contaminations typically present in ferritic steels. In

general, higher additions of these alloying elements bring about an embrittlement of the material,
particularly at the alloy grain boundaries.
Advantageously, the alloy contains between 12 and 28 wt%, and preferably between 17 and 25
wt%, of chromium. The steel then becomes a chromium oxide forming agent. At high
temperatures, particularly in a high-temperature fuel cell, it forms a protective oxidic cover layer
based on chromium. As a result of the cover layer, the steel is protected from corrosion,
particularly in the oxidic atmosphere of a fuel cell. The chromium content necessary for forming
the cover layer depends on the operating temperature at which the steel is used, and can be
determined by the person skilled in the art without undue experimentation. In general, higher
operating temperatures require higher chromium contents.
The cover layer is particularly advantageous in high-temperature fuel cells as it forms
spontaneously at normal operating temperatures ranging between 600 and 1000°C. As a result,
it is automatically self-healing if defects should occur. This is particularly advantageous if the
cell is exposed to frequent temperature changes due to startup and shutdown. Under such
conditions, the service life of the fuel cell is thus increased.
The chromium content can also be used to adjust the coefficient of thermal expansion of the
steel. This is particularly advantageous if the steel is used to produce an interconnector plate
(bipolar plate) for a fuel cell stack. In such a stack, one side of the plate is firmly mechanically
connected to the cathode material of a cell, and the other side of the plate is connected to the
anode material of the other cell. If the coefficient of expansion of the bipolar plate differs too
greatly from that of the cathode or anode material, high mechanical stresses occur. These may
cause a tearing of the cathode, anode, or the solid electrolyte provided between the cathode
and anode of a cell, resulting in the failure of the cell. Typically, between 800°C and room
temperature, the coefficient of thermal expansion of a ferritic steel, which comprises chromium
as the only substantial alloying element is about 16*10-6 K-1 at a chromium content of 9% and
about 13*10-6 K-1 at a chromium content of 22%.
Advantageously, the alloy comprises at least one element having oxygen affinity, such as
yttrium, lanthanum, zirconium, cerium or hafnium, in the case of the chromium oxide-forming
agent. The total concentration of elements having oxygen affinity in the alloy can range between
0.01 and 1 wt%, and preferably between 0.05 and 0.3 wt%. The addition of an element having
oxygen affinity, or a combination of a plurality of elements having oxygen affinity, effects a

reduction in the growth rate and an improvement in the adhesion of the oxidic chromium-based
cover layer. This is advantageous, since high growth rates result in a rapid reduction of the wall
thickness of thin components. In addition, as a result of high growth rates, the critical thickness
resulting in flaking of the oxide layers is achieved after only a short time, thereby unacceptably
inhibiting the gas flow in the narrow gas ducts of a high-temperature fuel cell.
The alloy may also contain the element having oxygen affinity in the form of an oxide dispersion,
such as Y2O3, La2O3, or ZrO2. The concentration of the respective oxide dispersion in the alloy
should then range between 0.1 and 2 wt%, and preferably between 0.4 and 1 wt%. The
advantage of the oxide dispersion compared to the introduction in a metal form is that the high-
temperature resistance is increased. Steels having oxide dispersions can be produced, for
example, by means of powder metallurgy.
The alloy advantageously comprises an element E, which forms a spinel phase with Cr2O3 of
the ECr2O4 type, on the surface of the steel, at temperatures above 500°C. Examples of such
elements are manganese, nickel, cobalt and copper, with manganese having been proven to be
particularly suited. The concentration of the element E in the alloy should range between 0.05 to
2 wt%, and preferably 0.2 to 1 wt%. As a result of the spinel formation, the workpiece causes
the evaporation of fewer volatile chromium compounds than would be the case with a workpiece
that forms a pure chromium oxide cover layer. Such volatile chromium compounds are
particularly undesirable on the inside of a high-temperature fuel cell, since they are catalyst
poisons and permanently reduce cell performance. Due to the spinel formation on the chromium
oxide layer, for example, the evaporation of volatile chromium compounds at 800°C in moist air
is reduced by a factor of 5 to 20.
In a further advantageous embodiment of the invention, the alloy has less than 0.5 wt%,
preferably less than 0.15 wt%, of aluminum. In this way, aluminum oxide inclusions are
prevented from forming in the steel in the zone beneath the chromium-based oxide cover layer
at high temperatures, particularly at the alloy grain boundaries. These inclusions must be
avoided as they disadvantageously impact the mechanical properties of the steel and
furthermore bring about a formation of metal inclusions in the chromium oxide layer due to
volume increase. These metal inclusions in turn impair the protective properties of the chromium
oxide layer.
In addition, the low aluminum content notably prevents the formation of aluminum-rich,

electrically insulating oxide layers on the surface of the steel. Such oxide layers have a
particularly disadvantageous effect if the steel is used to produce the bipolar plate for a fuel cell
stack. The current produced by the fuel cell stack must cross all bipolar plates in the stack.
Consequently, insulating layers on these plates increase the internal resistance of the stack and
considerably reduce the power output.
Advantageously, the alloy has a low addition of titanium of less than 0.2 wt%, preferably less
than 0.1 wt%. At such low concentrations, extremely finely divided particles made of titanium-
oxide form beneath the chromium oxide cover layer at high temperatures. This brings about a
strengthening of the material inside this zone, whereby buckling of the surface due to oxidation-
induced stress is suppressed. At higher titanium concentrations, similar disadvantageous effects
occur as with excessive aluminum contents.
Within the scope of the invention it was found that a bipolar plate that is made of the steel
according to the invention has particular advantages for use in a fuel cell stack, and particularly
for use in a bipolar plate for a fuel cell stack. The steel according to the invention can be tailored
so that the plate is oxidation-resistant at the typical operating temperatures of high-temperature
fuel cells, exhibits good electrical conductivity (including the oxide layers forming on the
surfaces), and has a low evaporation rate for volatile chromium compounds (chromium oxide
and/or chromium oxyhydroxide). In addition, the steel has a low coefficient of thermal expansion
(similar to the ceramic components of a high-temperature fuel cell). It can be hot and cold
formed and can also be machined using conventional methods. It was recognized that, based
on these advantageous characteristics, the power output and service life of a fuel cell stack can
be considerably increased by providing it with bipolar plates made of the steel according to the
invention.
The steel described here can also be used for other technical fields, in which high
oxidation/corrosion resistance and high creep resistance, combined with high electrical
conductivity for the chromium oxide layer formed during operation, are required, possibly with
the additional provision of low chromium evaporation. For example, it can be used for electrodes
or for electrode holders in liquid metals and melts. Furthermore, due to the special combination
of properties, it can be used as a production material for electric filters for flue gases and as a
heat conductor material or current collector for ceramic heat conductors, for example based on
molybdenum silicon or silicon carbide. The material can also be used in oxygen detectors, such
as Lambda probes. Steam-conducting pipes in power plants constitute a further field of

application.
To this end, the novel material can replace presently used ferritic 9-12% Cr steels, particularly if
the operating temperatures are raised from the presently typical range of 500 to 550°C to 600 to
700°C, with a view to better efficiency.
SPECIFIC DESCRIPTION
The object of the invention will be explained in more detail below with reference to the
embodiments and figures, without thereby limiting the object of the invention. Shown are:
FIG. 1: Oxide layer 13 on an alloy 11 made of iron, chromium, manganese and lanthanum.
FIG. 2: Oxide layer 13 on an alloy 21 made of iron, chromium, manganese and lanthanum with
the addition of titanium.
FIG. 3: Oxide layer 13 on an alloy 31 made of iron, chromium, manganese and lanthanum with
the addition of titanium and substitution by silicon.
FIG. 4: Oxide layer on an alloy 41 made of iron, chromium, manganese, lanthanum, niobium
and tungsten, comprising a niobium-rich oxide layer 47 disposed between the oxide layer 13
and alloy 41.
FIG. 5: Oxide layer 13 on an alloy 51 made of iron, chromium, manganese, lanthanum, niobium
and tungsten with substitution by silicon.
FIG. 6: Precipitations (56) of the Fe2(M, Si) type at alloy grain boundaries and precipitations (55)
of the Fe2(M, Si) type in the alloy grain.
The compositions listed below for an interconnector alloy (bipolar plate) have proven to be
particularly advantageous with respect to the coefficient of expansion thereof, the creep
resistance thereof, the oxidation resistance thereof, and the electrical conductivity of the oxidic
cover layer. The percentages refer to wt% in each case.
1. Iron-based, 21 to 23% chromium, 0.2 to 0.6% manganese, 0.05 to 0.15% lanthanum, 0.4 to
1% niobium, 0.3 to 0.6% silicon, less than 0.1% aluminum, 0.001 to 0.02% carbon.

2. Iron-based, 21 to 23% chromium, 0.2 to 0.6% manganese, 0.05 to 0.15% lanthanum, 0.4 to
1% niobium, 0.3 to 0.6% silicon, 0.04 to 0.1% titanium, less than 0.1% aluminum, 0.001 to
0.04% carbon.
3. Iron-based, 21 to 23% chromium, 0.2 to 0.6% manganese, 0.05 to 0.15% lanthanum, 0.2 to
0.6% niobium, 1.5 to 3.5% tungsten, 0.3 to 0.6% silicon, less than 0.05 % aluminum.
4. Iron-based, 21 to 23% chromium, 0.2 to 0.6% manganese, 0.05 to 0.15% lanthanum, 0.2 to
0.6% niobium, 1.5 to 3.5% tungsten, 0.3 to 0.6% silicon, 0.04 to 0.1% titanium, less than 0.08 %
aluminum, 0.001 to 0.01% carbon.
5. Iron-based, 21 to 23% chromium, 0.2 to 0.6% manganese, 0.05 to 0.15% lanthanum, 3.0 to
5.0% tungsten, 0.1 to 0.6% silicon, 0.02 to 0.1% titanium, less than 0.08 % aluminum, 0.001 to
0.01% carbon.
6. Iron-based, 21 to 23% chromium, 0.2 to 0.6% manganese, 0.05 to 0.15% lanthanum, 5.0 to
7.0% tungsten, 0.2 to 0.8 % silicon, 0.02 to 0.1% titanium, less than 0.08 % aluminum, 0.001 to
0.01% carbon.
The microstructural conditions of the novel alloy and the influence on oxide growth rates shall
be described again with reference to the alloy mentioned in number 4:
FIG. 1 shows an oxide layer 13 on an iron-based alloy 11 comprising 21 to 23% chromium, 0.2
to 0.6% manganese and 0.05 to 0.15% lanthanum, with alloy grain boundaries 12. The oxide
layer 13 made of Cr2O3 and Cr2MnO4 forms at 800°C in air.
FIG. 2 shows the oxide layer 13 on an alloy 21, to which 0.02 to 0.1% titanium was added as
compared to the alloy 11 according to FIG. 1. As a result, fine inner oxidation particles of Ti
oxide form beneath the Cr2O3 layer.
FIG. 3 shows the oxide layer 13 on an alloy 31, which additionally comprises 0.3 to 0.6% silicon,
as compared to the alloy 21 according to FIG. 2. Due to the addition of silicon, precipitations of
SiO2 form at, and in the vicinity of, the interface between the alloy and oxide. These bring about
the undesirable formation of metal inclusions 34 and an increase in the oxidation rate. The oxide
layer is therefore considerably thicker than in FIGS. 1 and 2. The formation of metal inclusions
and the increase in the oxidation rate also occur if 0.3 to 0.6% silicon is added to a titanium-free
alloy (see also FIG. 1).

FIG. 4 shows the oxide layer 13 on an alloy 41, to which 0.2 to 0.6% niobium and 1.5 to 3.5%
tungsten were added, as compared to the alloy 11 according to FIG. 1. A niobium-rich oxide
layer 47 is located between the oxide layer 13 and the alloy 41. Due to the addition of niobium
and tungsten, precipitations 45 of the Fe2M type form in the alloy grain. Precipitations 46 of the
Fe2M type form at the alloy grain boundaries, thereby providing the alloy with higher creep
resistance. The disadvantage, however, is that the oxidation rate is drastically increased. After
the same aging time, the oxide layer on the alloy 41 is considerably thicker than on the alloy 11.
Additional doping with 0.02 to 0.1% titanium would bring about fine inner oxidation particles as
is shown in FIGS. 2 and 3.
FIG. 5 shows the embodiment according to the invention comprising the oxide layer 13 on an
alloy 51, to which 0.2 to 0.6% niobium, 1.5 to 3.5% tungsten and 0.3 to 0.6% silicon were added,
as compared to the alloy 11 according to FIG. 1. As a result, precipitations 55 of the Fe2(M, Si)
type form in the alloy grain. Precipitations 56 of the Fe2(M, Si) type form at the alloy grain
boundaries. Due to the precipitations 55 and 56, the alloy is provided with higher creep
resistance. In contrast to the alloy 41 according to FIG. 4, the oxidation rate is not increased by
the addition of the Nb and W elements, as compared to the alloy 11 from FIG. 1. After the same
aging time, the oxide layer on the alloy 51 according to FIG. 5 has a similar thickness as that on
the alloy 11 according to FIG. 1. Additional doping with 0.02 to 0.1% titanium would bring about
fine inner oxidation particles as is shown in FIGS. 2 and 3.
FIG. 6 shows a scanning electron microscopic image of the precipitations 55 and 56 according
to FIG. 5.

NEW CLAIMS
1. A ferritic steel, comprising an iron-based alloy having at least
- 21 to 23 wt% chromium,
- 0.2 to 0.6 wt% manganese,
- 0.4 to 1.0 wt% niobium,
-1.5 to 3.5 wt% tungsten,
- 0.3 to 0.6 wt% silicon, and
- less than 0.15 wt% aluminum and
at least one element having oxygen affinity from the group consisting of yttrium, lanthanum,
zirconium, cerium or hafnium,
wherein the ferritic steel is able to form precipitations of an intermetallic phase of the Fe2(M, Si)
or Fe7(M, Si)6 type having at least two metal alloying elements M from the group M at
temperatures between 700°C and 900°C, where M = niobium, molybdenum, tungsten or
tantalum.
2. The steel according to claim 1, characterized in that the percentage of precipitations of the
intermetallic phase of the Fe2(M, Si) or Fe7(M, Si)6 type is between 1 and 8, and preferably
between 2.5 and 5 vol%.
3. Steel according to any one of claims 1 to 2, characterized in that the sum of precipitations of
the intermetallic phase of the Fe2(M, Si) and/or Fe7(M, Si)6 type comprises between 2 and 15
at% of silicon.
4. Steel according to any one of claims 1 to 3, characterized by an alloy in which the sum of the
concentrations of nickel and cobalt is greater than 0, however less than 4 wt%.
5. Steel according to any one of claims 1 to 4, characterized by an alloy in which the

concentrations of carbon, nitrogen, sulfur, boron and phosphorus are each greater than 0,
however less than 0.1 wt%, preferably less than 0.02 wt%.
6. Steel according to any one of claims 1 to 5, characterized by an alloy having a total
concentration of elements having oxygen affinity of between 0.01 and 1 wt%, and particularly
between 0.05 and 0.3 wt%.
7. Steel according to any one of claims 1 to 6, characterized by an alloy comprising the element
having oxygen affinity in the form of an oxide dispersion.
8. The steel according to claim 7, characterized by a concentration of the oxide dispersion in the
alloy of between 0.1 and 2 wt%, and particularly between 0.4 and 1 wt%.
9. Steel according to any one of claims 1 to 8, characterized by an alloy comprising an element
E, which forms a spinel phase of the ECr2O4 type with Cr2O3 on the surface of the steel at
temperatures above 500°C.

10. The steel according to claim 9, characterized by an element E from the group consisting of
manganese, nickel, cobalt, and copper.
11. A steel according to any one of claims 9 to 10, characterized by an alloy comprising
between 0.05 and 2 wt%, particularly between 0.2 and 1 wt% of the element E.
12. Steel according to any one of claims 1 to 11, characterized by an alloy comprising an
addition of titanium of less than 0.2 wt%, and particularly less than 0.1 wt%.
13. Use of a steel according to any one of claims 1 to 12 in a fuel cell stack.
14. Use of a steel according to any one of claims 1 to 13 in a bipolar plate for a fuel cell stack.

The invention relates to a ferritic steel that is particularly creep-resistant at temperatures from 600 to 1000°C and contains precipitations of an intermetallic phase Fe2 (M, Si) and/or Fe7 (M, Si), where M is a metal, in particular niobium, molybdenum, tungsten and/or tantalum. The precipitations may be formed during its production, during a heat treatment or during use at high temperature. The metal is partially substituted by silicon. As a result, it is possible to introduce considerably more creep-resistance enhancing precipitations into the steel than on the basis of the prior art, without thereby impairing the oxidation resistance of the material. If the alloy additionally contains chromium, the steel can be made into a chromium-oxide forming steel, which can be used inter alia for the bipolar plate in a stack of high-temperature fuel cells. The bipolar plate can be designed in such a way that its oxidic surface layer has good electrical conductivity and low chromium evaporation.

Documents:

3285-KOLNP-2008-(21-05-2014)-ANNEXURE TO FORM 3.pdf

3285-KOLNP-2008-(21-05-2014)-CLAIMS.pdf

3285-KOLNP-2008-(21-05-2014)-CORRESPONDENCE.pdf

3285-KOLNP-2008-(21-05-2014)-DESCRIPTION (COMPLETE).pdf

3285-KOLNP-2008-(21-05-2014)-DRAWINGS.pdf

3285-KOLNP-2008-(21-05-2014)-FORM-13.pdf

3285-KOLNP-2008-(21-05-2014)-FORM-2.pdf

3285-KOLNP-2008-(21-05-2014)-PA.pdf

3285-KOLNP-2008-(21-05-2014)-PETITION UNDER RULE 137.pdf

3285-KOLNP-2008-(21-11-2013)-CORRESPONDENCE.pdf

3285-KOLNP-2008-(21-11-2013)-OTHERS-1.pdf

3285-KOLNP-2008-(21-11-2013)-OTHERS.pdf

3285-kolnp-2008-abstract.pdf

3285-KOLNP-2008-ASSIGNMENT.pdf

3285-kolnp-2008-claims.pdf

3285-KOLNP-2008-CORRESPONDENCE-1.1.pdf

3285-kolnp-2008-correspondence.pdf

3285-kolnp-2008-description (complete).pdf

3285-kolnp-2008-drawings.pdf

3285-kolnp-2008-form 1.pdf

3285-KOLNP-2008-FORM 18.pdf

3285-kolnp-2008-form 3.pdf

3285-kolnp-2008-form 5.pdf

3285-kolnp-2008-international preliminary examination report.pdf

3285-kolnp-2008-international publication.pdf

3285-kolnp-2008-international search report.pdf

3285-KOLNP-2008-PCT PRIORITY DOCUMENT NOTIFICATION.pdf

3285-kolnp-2008-pct request form.pdf

3285-kolnp-2008-specification.pdf


Patent Number 264160
Indian Patent Application Number 3285/KOLNP/2008
PG Journal Number 50/2014
Publication Date 12-Dec-2014
Grant Date 10-Dec-2014
Date of Filing 11-Aug-2008
Name of Patentee FORSCHUNGSZENTRUM JÜLICH GMBH
Applicant Address WILHELM-JOHNEN-STRASSE, 52425 JÜLICH
Inventors:
# Inventor's Name Inventor's Address
1 ENNIS, PHILIP, JAMES GERHART-HAUPTMANN-STR. 10, 41844 WEGBERG
2 QUADAKKERS, WILLEM, J. ZINKENSTRAAT 4A, 6363 EG WIJNANDSRADE
3 NIEWOLAK, LESZEK LINNICHERSTR. 19, 52428 JÜLICH
PCT International Classification Number C22C 38/00,H01M 8/02
PCT International Application Number PCT/DE2007/000166
PCT International Filing date 2007-01-31
PCT Conventions:
# PCT Application Number Date of Convention Priority Country
1 10 2006 007 598.6 2006-02-18 Germany