Title of Invention

HIGH-RESOLUTION RAPID MANUFACTURING

Abstract A method for forming an object, the method comprising jetting a first material to form a plurality of layers (70) that define a support structure increment (72), and extruding a second material to form a layer (74) of the object (38). The layer (74) of the object (38) substantially conforms to an interior surface (68) of the support structure increment (72).
Full Text HIGH-RESOLUTION RAPID MANUFACTURING
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
The present invention relates to the fabrication of three-
dimensional objects from computer designs using additive process
techniques. In particular, the present invention relates to the rapid
manufacturing of three-dimensional objects using fused deposition
modeling and jetting techniques.
Rapid prototyping of three-dimensional objects from
computer-generated designs is used to form parts for a variety of
functions, such as aesthetic judgments, proofing a mathematical model,
concept visualization, forming hard tooling, studying interference and
space allocation, and testing functionality. Rapid prototyping techniques
have also spread into rapid manufacturing markets, where copies of an
object are quickly created, and each object exhibits physical properties
comparable to objects made from hard tooling.
Rapid manufacturing applications demand a high
throughput, a good surface finish, and strengths, toughness, and
chemical resistance equaling that of injection-molded parts. To achieve
the desired functional qualities, it is desirable to build rapid manufactured
objects out of thermoplastic materials, such as acrylonitrile butadiene
styrene (ABS), polycarbonate, and polysulfone, all of which exhibit good
physical properties.
Fused deposition modeling is a popular rapid prototyping
technique developed by Stratasys, Inc., Eden Prairie, MN, which builds
three-dimensional objects from thermoplastics materials. Fused
deposition modeling machines build three-dimensional objects by
extruding flowable modeling material (e.g., thermoplastic materials)
through a nozzle carried by an extrusion head, and depositing the

2
modeling material in a predetermined pattern onto a base. The modeling
material is extruded in fluent strands, referred to as "roads". Typically, the
object is formed in a layer-wise fashion by depositing a sequence of
roads in an x-y plane, incrementing the position of the extrusion head
along a z-axis (perpendicular to the x-y plane), and then repeating the
process. Movement of the extrusion head with respect to the base is
performed under computer control, in accordance with design data
provided from a computer aided design (CAD) system. The extruded
modeling material fuses to previously deposited modeling material, and
solidifies upon a drop in temperature to form a three-dimensional object
resembling the CAD model.
Another technique for building objects from solidifiable
materials is known as jetting, which deposits droplets of modeling
material from nozzles of a jetting head, such as an inkjet printhead. After
dispensing, the jetted material is solidified (e.g., cured by exposing the
material to ultraviolet radiation).
The surfaces of three-dimensional objects developed from
layered manufacturing techniques of the current art (e.g., fused
deposition modeling and jetting) are textured or striated due to their
layered formation. Curved and angled surfaces generally have a "stair
step" appearance, caused by layering of cross-sectional shapes which
have square edge profiles. Although the stair-stepping does not effect
the strength of the object, it does detract aesthetically. Generally, the
stair-stepping effect is proportional to the layer thickness, and decreases
as the layer thickness decreases.
Current fused deposition modeling machines, such as
systems commercially available from Stratasys, Inc., build three-
dimensional objects having layer thicknesses ranging from about 180

3
micrometers (about 0.007 inches) to about 760 micrometers (about 0.030
inches) and road widths ranging from about 125 micrometers (about
0.005 inches) to about 1500 micrometers (about 0.060 inches).
Thermoplastic materials flow through extrusion tips having inner
diameters typically ranging from about 125 micrometers (about 0.005
inches) to about 500 micrometers (about 0.020 inches), at dispensing
rates designed to produce the desired layer thicknesses and road widths.
The fused deposition modeling machines generally operate
at voxel rates of about 500 hertz (Hz), extruding thermoplastic materials
at a dispensing rate of about three cubic inches per hour. The resulting
object resolution is generally about 130 micrometers (about 0.005
inches), depending on the object geometry. The high viscosities of
thermoplastic materials (e.g., about 500 Poise) and their low thermal
conductivities (e.g., about 0.2 watts/meter-EC) generally constrains the
extrusion of these plastics through a smaller extrusion tip (to produce
thinner layers) while moving the extruder at a higher frequency (to
decrease build time).
Jetting techniques of the current art can eject small droplets
of material at a voxel rate of about 2 kilohertz (kHz) to about 200 kHz.
The thicknesses of jetted layers generally range from about 5
micrometers (about 0.0002 inches) to about 150 micrometers (about
0.006 inches), with a typical thickness before planarization of about 25
micrometers (about 0.001 inches). Accordingly, the resulting object
resolution is generally about 50 micrometers (about 0.002 inches),
depending on the object geometry. However, known jettable materials do
not have the desirable material properties of the extrudable thermoplastic
materials. As such, jetted objects are generally less suitable for rapid
manufacturing applications. There is a need for techniques that increase

4
the speed and resolution of building three-dimensional objects from
materials that exhibit good physical properties, such as thermoplastic
materials.
BRIEF SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
The present invention relates to a method and system that
provide a high-resolution, rapidly manufactured, three-dimensional object
by combining jetting techniques with the principles of fused deposition
modeling. A first material is jetted to form a plurality of layers that define
an increment of a support structure. The jetting allows the increment of
the support structure to have a high-resolution interior surface.
A second material is extruded to form a layer of the three-
dimensional object, where the layer of the three-dimensional object
substantially conforms to the high-resolution interior surface of the
increment of the support structure. The jetting and the extrusion are
repeated until the three-dimensional object and the support structure are
formed. Accordingly, the support structure functions as a high-resolution
mold that is filled concurrently with its construction. This allows three-
dimensional objects to be formed from materials with good physical
properties, at high deposition rates, and with high surface resolutions.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
FIG. 1 is a side view of a three-dimensional modeling
system of the present invention with a portion broken away.
FIG. 2 is a front view of the three-dimensional modeling
system of the present invention with a portion broken away.
FIG. 3 is a illustration of a camera monitoring deposited
layers.

5
FIG. 4 is a diagram illustrating a build process pursuant to
the present invention.
FIG. 5 is an illustration of material layers deposited pursuant
to the present invention.
FIGS. 6A-6D are schematic representations of a three-
dimensional object and a support structure under construction.
FIG. 7 is a illustration of the three-dimensional object and a
support structure as shown in FIG. 6A, depicting an extruded thin-road
wall approach.
FIG. 8 is an illustration of the three-dimensional object and a
support structure as shown in FIG. 7.
FIG. 9 is a illustration of the three-dimensional object and a
support structure as shown in FIG. 6A, depicting a chinking approach.
FIG. 10 is a illustration of the three-dimensional object and a
support structure as shown in FIG. 6A, depicting a lost wax approach.
FIG. 11 is a illustration of the three-dimensional object and a
support structure as shown in FIG. 6A, depicting a support stilts
approach.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION
FIGS. 1 and 2 are respectively a side view and a front view
of a three-dimensional modeling system 10, which is an apparatus for
manufacturing three-dimensional objects pursuant to the present
invention. The system 10 includes a build chamber 12, a controller 14, a
CAD system 16, a material supply portion 18, and a circulation system
20.
The build chamber 12 includes chamber walls 22 and an
interior portion 24 disposed within the chamber walls 22. The interior
portion 24 is shown as a broken away portion in FIGS. 1 and 2. Within

6
the interior portion 24, the build chamber 12 also includes a jetting head
26, a planarizer 28, an extrusion head 30, guide rails 32, a platform 34, a
support structure 36, and a three-dimensional object 38. As discussed
below, the jetting head 26 jets a support material onto the platform 34 to
build the support structure 36 in increments. Interspersed with the jetting
of the support structure 36, the extrusion head 30 extrudes a modeling
material onto the platform 34 to build the object 38 within the support
structure 36.
The jetting head 26 and the planarizer 28 are coupled
together as a single unit, and are supported by the guide rails 32, which
extend along a y-axis within the build chamber 12. This allows the jetting
head 26 and the planarizer 28 to move back-and-forth along the y-axis.
The extrusion head 30 is supported by the guide rails 32 and by
additional guide rails 40, where the additional guide rails 40 extend along
an x-axis within the build chamber 12. The guide rails 32 and 40 allow
the extrusion head 30 to move in any direction in a plane defined by the
x-axis and the y-axis.
The platform 34 provides a working surface for building the
support structure 36 and the object 38, and is disposed below the jetting
head 26, the planarizer 28, and the extrusion head 30 in a direction along
a z-axis. The height of the platform 34 along the z-axis may be adjusted
in a conventional manner to vary the distance between the platform 34
and the jetting head 26, the planarizer 28, and the extrusion head 30.
The material supply portion 18 includes a support material
supply 42, a modeling material supply 44, a support material supply line
46, a support material return line 48, and a modeling material supply line
50. The support material supply 42 is connected to the jetting head 26 of
the build chamber 12 with the support material supply line 46, which

7
allows support material stored in the support material supply 42 to be
pumped to the jetting head 26. Support material left unused after building
the support structure 36 may be transported back to the support material
supply 42 via the support material return line 48. The modeling material
supply 44 is connected to the extrusion head 30 of the build chamber 12
with the modeling material supply line 50, which allows modeling material
stored in the modeling material supply 44 to be transferred to the
extrusion head 30.
The circulation system 20 includes a vacuum 54, a cooling
fan 56, a vacuum conduit 58, and a cooling conduit 60. The vacuum 54 is
connected to the planarizer 28 of the build chamber 16 with the vacuum
conduit 58. Similarly, the cooling fan 56 is connected to the extrusion
head 30 of the build chamber 16 with the cooling conduit 60. The cooling
fan 56 provides cool air to the extrusion head 30 to maintain the extrusion
head 30 at a desired temperature.
The jetting head 26 of the build chamber 12 includes an
array of downward facing jets 62, which eject droplets of support material
according to a predetermined pattern to build the support structure 36,
layer-by-layer. In the present embodiment, the jets 62 span the entire
work space in single array. In order to nullify the effects of a
malfunctioning nozzle (e.g., a clogged or dead nozzle), the jetting head
26 may shift along the x-axis to randomize the locations of the jets 62
relative to the work space. This may be accomplished with the use of
third set of guide rails (not shown) that extend along the x-axis, parallel to
the guide rails 40 for the extrusion head 30. In alternative embodiments,
the jets 62 may only span a portion of the work space, with the jetting
head 26 making multiple passes in order to cover the entire work space at
each incremental height along the z-axis (e.g., raster scan and interlaced

8
raster scan patterns). Additionally, the jets 62 may be offset at an angle
from the x-axis to increase the resolution of each pass (e.g., a saber
angle).
The jetting head 26 may be a commercial inkjet printhead,
such as trade designated GALAXY, NOVA, and SPECTRA
printheads/jetting assemblies, all of which are commercially available
from Spectra, Inc. Lebanon, NH. In one embodiment, the jetting head 26
uses drop-on-demand technology. A typical jetting head of the current
art, using drop-on-demand technology, reliably ejects droplets with about
38 micrometer diameters at a rate of about three kHz per nozzle, and has
a nozzle density of more than 300 nozzles per inch. In an alternative
embodiment, the jetting head 26 uses continuous drop technology.
Continuous drop technology generally provides a higher throughput, but
the droplet size has more variability. In another alternative embodiment,
the jetting head 26 may be customized and/or may have as few as one
jet. For example, the jetting head 26 may move rapidly along the y-axis
and electrostatically deflect droplets into position.
In the jetting heads of the current art, the droplets ejected
exhibit variable sizes, which results in a deposition rate uncertainty. To
address this uncertainty, the jetting head 26 is calibrated to over-deposit
the support material. The excess material may then be subsequently
removed by the planarizer 28. The planarizer 28 may be any instrument
suitable for planarizing the deposited layers. In the present embodiment,
the planarizer 28 is a rotating cutter, which planarizes layers the support
structure by physically cutting away the support material. Alternatively,
the planarizer 28 may be solvent-assisted lapping planarizer, which
incorporates a solvent-coated roller that dissolve portions of the support
structure 36. This is particularly suitable for use with small features of the

9
support structure 36, which may otherwise be damaged by the shear
forces induced by conventional planarizers. Another alternative for the
planarizer 28 includes a smooth roller that is particularly suitable for use
with certain materials of the support structure 36, as discussed below.
The planarizer 28 desirably extends slightly below the jetting
head 14. In this arrangement, the jetted support material is planarized
when it builds up to a height along the z-axis equal to the height of the
planarizer 28. This prevents the jets 62 from colliding with the jetted
layers of the support structure 36. In alternative embodiments, the
planarizer 28 may be de-coupled from the jetting head 26, allowing the
planarizer 28 to be positionable at various heights along the z-axis. This
provides control of the intervals at which the planarizer 28 acts upon the
jetted support material.
The support material removed by the planarizer 28 is
withdrawn from the build chamber 16 through the vacuum conduit 58 by
the vacuum 54. The vacuum 46 pulls material away from the build
chamber 16 as the material is removed by the planarizer 28. The
planarizer 28 and the vacuum 54 may be any suitable planarizer system
for planarizing and removing excess support material. For example, in
lieu of the vacuum 54, a negatively-charged static roller may be used to
collect and remove the excess support material while the planarizer 28 is
in use.
The extrusion head 30 may be of any type that receives a
thermoplastic material and dispenses the thermoplastic material in a
molten state, such as an extrusion head for fuse deposition modeling.
The extrusion head 30 includes an extrusion tip 64, which extrudes bulk
layers of modeling material according to a predetermined pattern to build
the object 38, layer-by-layer. In one embodiment of the present invention,

10
the extrusion tip 64 of the extrusion head 30 may include a large orifice,
capable of extruding thicker bulk layers of modeling material than
generally used with existing fuse deposition modeling systems.
An example of a suitable thickness for the bulk layers of
modeling material includes about 760 micrometers (0.03 inches). This is
several times greater than used with current fuse deposition modeling
systems. The terms "thickness" and "layer thickness" are defined herein
as distances along the z-axis shown in FIGS 1 and 2. The large orifices
of the extrusion tip 64 also allow the extrusion rates of the modeling
material to be higher than the rates of existing fuse deposition modeling
systems. An example of a suitable extrusion flow rate from the extrusion
tip 64 includes at least about 1.6 liters/hour (about 100 inches3 /hour). In
comparison, extrusion rates of existing fuse deposition modeling systems
are about 0.05 liters/hours (about 3 inches3/hour).
The jetting head 26, the planarizer 28, the extrusion head
30, and the platform 34 of the build chamber 14 are each managed by the
controller 14. The controller 14 may be any suitable computer system for
receiving data from the CAD system 16 and directing deposition and
planarization patterns for the support structure 36 and the object 38.
The CAD system 16 provides a digital representation of the
object 38 to the controller 14, from which the extrusion pattern for the
extrusion head 30 is determined. The CAD system 16 also creates a
digital representation of the support structure 36 from the digital
representation of the object 38. In one embodiment, the CAD system 16
first identifies data representing an exterior surface of the object 38. The
CAD system 16 then creates the digital representation of the support
structure 36 in which the support structure 36 has an interior surface with
a geometry defined by the data representing the exterior surface of the

11
object 38. As such, the support structure 36 is designed as a matching
mold for the object 38. The CAD system 16 provides the digital
representation of the support structure 36 to the controller 14, from which
the jetting pattern for the jetting head 26 is determined.
As used herein, the term "exterior surface" of the object 38
includes all surfaces of the object 38 that are exposed to external
conditions, such as the geometric outside surface of the object 38,
exposed hollow portions of the object 38, and exposed channels that
extend within the object 38. As used herein, the term "interior surface" of
the support structure 36 includes all surfaces of the support structure 36
that geometrically correspond to the exterior surface of the object 38.
In alternative embodiments, the controller 14 and the CAD
system 16 may be a single system that provides the digital
representations of the support structure 36 and the object 38, and
manages the components of the system 10. Additionally, the digital
representation of the support structure 36 may be created through a
variety of data manipulation techniques.
The interior region 24 of the build chamber 12 is desirably
maintained at a temperature greater than the creep-relaxation
temperature of the modeling material. Building the object 38 in an
environment with a temperature higher than the creep-relaxation
temperature of the modeling material, followed by a gradual cooling,
relieves stresses imposed on the object 38. If the environment is too
cool, the thermal gradient between the newly-extruded hot modeling
material and the cooled pre-existing modeling material, together with the
thermal expansion coefficient of the modeling material, generates a warp
or curl. On the other hand, if the environment is too hot, the modeling
material will not adequately solidify, and the object 38 will droop.

12
Examples of suitable temperatures for the interior region 24
of the build chamber 16 range from about the solidification temperature of
the modeling material to about the glass transition temperature of the
modeling material. Examples of particularly suitable temperatures for the
build chamber 16 range from about the creep-relaxation temperature of
the modeling material to about the glass transition temperature of the
modeling material.
When the interior region 24 of the build chamber 16 is
maintained at about the glass transition temperature of the modeling
material, the modeling material slumps and substantially conforms to the
interior surface of the support structure 36. As such, the support structure
36 functions in a similar manner to a mold of an injection molding
process. However, in contrast to the high pressures at which plastic are
shot into an injection mold, the extruded roads of modeling material in the
present invention will exert low pressures (primarily hydrostatic
pressures) on the support structure 36. Therefore, the support structure
36 is only required to exhibit moderate strengths to support the object 38.
It is desirable to thermally isolate the jetting head 26 from
the interior region 24 of the build chamber 16. Prolonged high
temperatures may potentially degrade the support materials and/or the
jetting head 26. Various means may be used to shield the jetting head
26 from the heat. For example, the jetting head 26 may be cooled by
pumping cool air with the a second cooling fan (not shown) that shares
the vacuum conduit 58 with the vacuum 54. Other shielding techniques
may be used, as will be apparent to those skilled in the art, including a
deformable baffle insulator, as is disclosed in Swanson et al., U.S. Patent
No. 6,722,872, which is incorporated herein by reference in its entirety.

13
In order to accurately build the support structure 36 and the
object 38, the controller 14 registers the relative positions between the
jetting head 26 (in directions along the y-axis) and the extrusion head 30
(in directions along the x-axis and the y-axis). Sensors may communicate
with the controller 14 to perform registration on start-up, and to monitor
registration of the jetting head 26 and the extrusion head 30 during a build
process.
When implementing the present invention, the planarizer 28
is desirably positioned to avoid collisions with the object 38. Similarly, the
extrusion tip 64 of the extrusion head 30 is desirably positioned to avoid
collisions with the support structure 36. In one embodiment, the
planarizer 28 planarizes the jetted support material to a height along the
z-axis that is slightly below the position of the extrusion tip 64. This
effectively prevents the extrusion tip 64 from colliding with the support
structure 36 as the extrusion head 30 travels across the work space. In
an alternative embodiment, collision may be avoided by lowering the
platform 34 before the extrusion and raising it back up after the extrusion
is completed.
In addition to avoiding collision, registration is also important
for building the support structure 36 and the object 38 with accurate
geometries. In order to ensure that the layers of support material and
modeling material are progressing at the same height along the z-axis.
registration must be maintained between the planarizer 28 and the
extrusion tip 64 of the extrusion head 30. As such, the system 10 of the
present invention may include sensors to register and to maintain
registration between the various components of the system 10 to avoid
collisions, and to monitor the deposited materials.

14
FIG. 3 is an illustration of the layers of the support structure
36 and the object 38 being monitored by a camera 76. The camera 76 is
an optical ranging sensor that maintains registration during a build
process by monitoring the relative heights of the support structure 36 and
the object 38. The camera 76 senses the heights along the z-axis of the
support structure 36 and the object 38. The camera 76 then compares
the heights to determine if further jetting, extrusion, planarization, or other
actions should be taken. Feedback from sensors, such as the camera
76, may also be used to determine how many layers of support material
are jetted. If the height of the support structure 36 is below a desired
height, additional layers of support material may be jetted and planarized.
Alternatively, if the height of the support structure exceeds a desired
height, subsequent jetting of layers of support material may be halted.
The system 10 allows the formation of the support structure
36 and the object 38 pursuant to the present invention. Based on the
digital representation of the support structure 36, the jetting head 26 jets
support material to build the support structure 36. Similarly, based on the
digital representation of the object 38, the extrusion head 30 extrudes
modeling material to build the object 38. This build process allows the
support structure 36 to function as a high resolution mold for the object
38.
FIG. 4 is a diagram illustrating a build process of the support
structure 36 and the object 38 with the system 10 described in FIGS. 1
and 2. FIG. 3 includes building steps 66a-66d, in which the support
structure 36 and the object 38 are built on the platform 34, where the
support structure 36 has an high-resolution interior surface 68. In step
66a, the jet 64 deposits support material to form a jetted layer 70. This
further increases the height of the support structure 36 along the z-axis.

15
In step 66b, the support material of the jetted layer 70 substantially
solidifies, which may be performed in a variety of manners depending of
the support material used. Steps 66a and 66b are then repeated to form
N jetted layers of support material until a desired increment is reached,
where the desired increment has a thickness in a direction along the z-
axis. In one embodiment, N is an integer value of at least four (i.e., at
least four jetted layers are deposited). In another embodiment, N is an
integer value of at least ten (i.e., at least ten jetted layers are deposited).
The "substantial solidifying" of the jetted layers (e.g.. the
jetted layer 70) does not require that the support materials be completely
solidified before the subsequent jetted layer is deposited. The present
invention only requires that the layers of the support structure 58 are
capable of supporting subsequently deposited layers of the support
structure 58 and of supporting the object 56.
As shown in step 66c, after the desired increment of the
support structure 36 is reached, the planarizer 28 planarizes the
deposited support material. The dislodged material is then removed form
the build chamber 12 by the vacuum 54. In a typical jetting process of the
current art, the planarizing step removes from about 5% to about 50% of
a jetted layer's thickness, with a typical value of about 20%. Planarizing
after multiple layers of support material are jetted provides the benefit that
it is forgiving of small errors in the heights of the extruded layers of
modeling material. This is because planarizing the jetted support material
only after jetting several layers will generally avoid collision by the
planarizer 26 with the previously extruded layers of modeling material.
In an alternative embodiment, the height of the planarizer 28
may be set such that each layer of support material will be planarized
after being jetted, and prior to jetting the subsequent layer of support

16
material. In this case, care must be taken to ensure that the height of the
extruded layers of modeling material remains below the planarizer 28,
such as by using sensors.
As shown in step 66d, after planarization, the jetted layers
are reduced to a support structure increment 72 having a thickness t.
The extrusion head 30 then extrudes modeling material to fill the support
structure 36 and build the object 56. Inside the extrusion head 30, the
modeling material is heated to a flowable temperature (typically between
about 180°C and about 300°C, depending on the modeling material being
extruded). The incoming modeling material itself acts as a piston,
creating a pumping action that forces the melted modeling material to
extrude from the extrusion tip 64 of the extrusion head 30. The modeling
material is extruded adjacent to the interior surface 68 of the support
structure increment 72, to form a bulk layer 74 having a thickness t'. In
one embodiment of the present invention, the layer thickness t' for each
bulk layer of modeling material (e.g., the bulk layer 74) is approximately
equal to the layer thickness t for the corresponding support structure
increment (e.g., the support structure increment 72).
Steps 66a-66d are then continued, building and filling the
support structure 36, increment-by-increment, until the object 38 is
complete. The support structure according to the present invention (e.g.,
the support structure 36) may be immersive (i.e., fully surrounding the
completed object 38), omitted from the top and bottom surfaces of the
object 38, or omitted from the top surface of the object 38.
FIG. 5 is an illustration of a support structure increment of
the support structure 36 and the object 38, as described in FIG. 4. As
shown, the support structure 36 is formed from twenty-four jetted layers
36a-36x of support material, and includes the interior surface 68. The

17
object 38 is formed from three bulk layers 38a-38c of modeling material.
The dotted lines illustrate the initial shape of the bulk layers 38a-38c upon
extrusion. As discussed above, the interior region 24 of the build
chamber 12 may be maintained at a temperature that causes the
modeling material to slump and substantially conform to the interior
surface 68 of the support structure 36. This allows the object 38 to be
built with an exterior surface defined by the high resolution interior surface
68 of the support structure 36. In the embodiment shown in FIG. 5, eight
jetted layers (e.g., the jetted layers 38a-38h) are jetted per extruded bulk
layer (e.g., the bulk layer 38a). As such, the surface resolution of the
object 38 is increased eight-fold by imposing the jetted layer resolution on
the extruded bulk layers 38a-38c.
After the support structure 36 and the object 38 are built,
they may be removed from the heated environment of the build chamber
12 as a joined block. At this point, there may be thermal gradients in the
block that can generate significant forces on the support structure 36 as
the molding material solidifies. The cooling time required to prevent
significant thermal gradients generally depends on the size of the object
38. However, by the time the modeling material can generate significant
force, the modeling material is generally rigid enough to retain its shape
even if the support material cracks. Additionally, the use of support
materials with high thermal conductivities may increase the uniform
cooling of the object 38. Alternatively, after the support structure 36 and
the object 38 are constructed, holes may be formed through the support
structure 36 to allow coolant fluids to flow through. This may also
increase the uniform cooling of the object 38.
Upon completion, the support structure 36 may be removed
in any manner that does not substantially damage the object 38.

18
Examples of suitable techniques for removing the support structure 36
from the object 38 include physical removal (i.e., breaking the support
structure 36 apart with applied force), dissolving at least a portion of the
support structure in a solvent (discussed below), and combinations
thereof. After the support structure 36 is removed, the object 38 is
completed, and may undergo conventional post-building steps as
individual needs may require.
Examples of suitable modeling materials for use with the
present invention include any material that is extrudable with a fused
deposition modeling system. Examples of particularly suitable molding
materials include thermoplastic materials, such as ABS, polycarbonate,
polysulfone, and combinations thereof. The modeling material may be
supplied from the modeling material supply 44 in the form of a flexible
filament wound on a supply reel, or in the form of a solid rod, as disclosed
in Crump, U.S. Patent No. 5,121,329, which is incorporated by reference
in its entirety. Alternatively, the modeling material may be pumped in
liquid form from a reservoir.
The modeling materials may also be moisture sensitive. To
protect the integrity of moisture-sensitive modeling materials, the
modeling material supply 44 may be kept dry using an air tight filament
loading and drying system, such as is disclosed in Swanson et al., U.S.
Patent No. 6,685,866, which is incorporated herein by reference in its
entirety.
Examples of suitable support materials for use with the
present invention include any material that is jettable from an inkjet
printhead and that exhibits sufficient strength to support the modeling
material during the building process, such as solvent-dispersed materials,
ultraviolet-curable materials, and combinations thereof. The support

19
materials also desirably solidify quickly with a good surface finish, have
low deposition viscosities, are low cost, exhibit low environmental impact
(e.g., are non-toxic materials), are capable of withstanding the extrusion
temperatures of the modeling material for a short period of time, and are
capable of withstanding the temperature of the build chamber 12 for
extended periods of time.
Examples of particularly suitable support materials include
solvent-dispersed materials, such as a sucrose solution and a salt
solution. Examples of suitable component concentration for sucrose
solutions include about 73% by weight sucrose (C12H22O11) in water at
about 90°C, and about 80% by weight sucrose in water at about 120°C.
Each of these sucrose solutions exhibits a viscosity of about 18
centipoises. After jetting, the water solvent volatilizes in interior region 24
of the build chamber 16, which leaves the residual sucrose at the jetted
locations to build the support structure 36. Salt solutions, such as a
sodium chloride in water solution function in the same manner as sucrose
solutions, and also exhibit high thermal conductivities (about five
watts/meter-°C). This assists in the uniform cooling of the object 38.
In addition to being environmentally friendly, sucrose
solutions and salt solutions are also soluble in a variety of solvents. This
allows the support structure 36 to be removed by exposure to solvents,
such as water. For example, after the support structure 36 and the object
38 are built, the support structure 36 may be removed by dissolving, at
least a portion of, or all of the support structure 36 in water to expose the
finished object 38. This may be performed with minimal operator
attention and minimal damage to the geometry or strength of the object
38.

20
When building the support structure 36 and the object 38, it
is desirable to have low contact angles between the deposited materials.
The low contact angles increase the extent that the modeling material
conforms to the resolution of the support structure 36. However, low
contact angles also increase the bonding of the support materials and the
modeling materials at the interface between the support structure 36 and
the object 38. Physical removal of the support structure 36 may damage
the exterior surface of the object 38. As such, damage to the object 38
may be avoided by dissolving at least a portion of the support structure 36
in a solvent to remove the support structure 36.
The solubility of solvent-dispersed materials, such as
sucrose solutions and salt solutions, also allows the planarizer 28 to
include smooth planarizers. In this embodiment, portions of the jetted
solvent (e.g., water) remain non-volatilized with the sucrose/salt for
periods of time after jetting. The non-volatilized solvent assists the
planarizer 28 in removing the excess material of the support structure 36
in a manner similar to solvent-assisted lapping planarizers, except that
additional solvent is not required.
As discussed above, the present invention allows three-
dimensional objects to be formed from modeling materials that exhibit
good physical properties, and which are deposited in bulk layers at rapid
rates. The three-dimensional objects also exhibit high resolutions
obtained from the jetted support structures, which enhance the aesthetic
qualities of the three-dimensional objects. The present invention provides
a throughput rate for modeling material of at least about 0.5 liters/hour
(about 30 inches3 /hour), with an accuracy of about 51
micrometers/micrometer(about 0.002 inches/inch), and a surface finish of
about 30 micrometers (about 0.001 inches) root-mean-square.

21
As generally discussed above, it is necessary to build
support structures (e.g., the support structure 36) when creating three-
dimensional objects (e.g., the object 38) in a layer-wise fashion, to
support portions of the objects under construction. In the discussions of
FIGS. 1-5, the jetted layers of support material are sequentially deposited
to form interior surfaces (e.g., the interior surface 68) with angles up to
about 90 degrees. In these cases, each layer of support material is jetted
into an underlying layer of support material or modeling material.
However, some three-dimensional object geometries
require that support structures have interior surfaces that project at
angles substantially greater than 90 degrees. In these cases, portions of
layers of support material are jetted into areas without underlying support.
In such areas, particularly with interior surfaces having angles greater
than about 30 degrees off vertical, the jetted support material itself
requires additional support. These overhanging regions present a special
case, where modified build approaches may be used to compensate for
the lack of support at the overhanging regions.
FIGS. 6A-6D are schematic representations of a three-
dimensional object 100 and a support structure 102 under construction on
a platform 103. As shown in FIG. 6A, the support structure 102 includes
overhanging regions 104, which each have lateral portions that project
over the object 100 at angles substantially greater than 90 degrees.
These overhanging regions 104 require additional support. Figs. 6B and
6C show the continued building and completion of the part 100 in the
support structure 102. Fig. 6D shows the completed part 100, removed
from the support structure 102.
A number of approaches may be taken to support
overhanging support structure regions, such as those required to build the

22
object 100. Examples of suitable approaches include an extruded thin-
road wall approach, an extruded bulk-road wall approach, a chinking
approach, a lost wax approach, a support stilts approach, and a
thermoplastic ploughing approach. These approaches are described
below in FIGS. 7-11 with reference to an increment i of the overhanging
region 104.
FIGS. 7-11 are illustrations depicting the approaches to
taken support the overhanging region 104, and each include the object
100 (with bulk layers 100a-100c) and the overhanging region 104 of the
support structure 102, as shown in Fig. 6A.
FIGS. 7 and 8 depict the extruded thin-road wall approach
to support the overhanging region 104. As shown in FIG. 7, the extruded
thin-road wall approach involves pre-extruding thin layers 106 of modeling
material into the areas under the overhanging region 104 in the increment
i. This forms supporting walls on the bulk layer 100c, which provides
support to the overhanging region 104. The thin layers 106 may be
deposited from a second extrusion tip, which may be carried either by a
separate extrusion head or a second tip on the primary extrusion head
30. Alternatively, the extrusion tip 64 of the primary extrusion head 30
may include a size-adjustable orifice.
In one embodiment, the modeling material may be
deposited in M thin layers 106, where M is an integer greater than or
equal to 2. The thickness of each of the thin layers 106 is about t/M, so
that the thickness of the supporting walls (i.e., the increment i) is about
equal to the thickness t' of the bulk layers 100a-100c. As shown in FIG.
7, four thin layers 106 are extruded (i.e., M=4). When subsequent bulk
layers of modeling material (not shown) are extruded to fill the increment

23
i, the thin layers 106 and the bulk layers of modeling material fuse
together to form a unitary object 100.
Applying the thin layers 106 on the bulk layer 100c provides
a good surface finish in these regions where the modeling material is
applied before the adjacent sidewalls of the support structure 102 are
formed. Accordingly, the thin layers 106 are desirably applied in layers
no thicker than about half the thickness of a bulk layers 100a-100c, in
order to increase resolution. To match the surface finish of the rest of the
part, the thicknesses of the thin layers 106 may be about equal to the
thicknesses t of the support material layers.
As shown in FIG. 8, the overhanging region 104 is formed in
an increment / from support structure layers 104a-104h. The modeling
material is extruded in thin layers 106a-106d. The thin layers 106a-106d
form a supporting wall 108, which supports the support structure layers
104a-104h as they are jetted. The bulk layer 100d is deposited adjacent
the supporting wall 108 to fill the increment i. Because four thin layers
106 (i.e., the thin layers 106a-106d) were extruded, the surface resolution
of the object 100 at the increment i shown in FIGS. 7 and 8 will be four
times greater than by extrusion of the bulk layer 104d alone.
The extruded bulk-road wall approach is similar to the
extruded thin-road wall approach, except that bulk layers of modeling
material are pre-extruded into the areas under the overhanging region
104 prior to forming the overhanging region 104. When subsequent bulk
roads of modeling material are extruded to fill the support structure
increment i, the various bulk roads of modeling material fuse together to
form a unitary object 100. In contrast to the extruded thin-road wall
approach, after removing the support structure 102 from the object 100
formed by the extruded bulk-road approach, the pre-extruded areas of the

24
object 100 will exhibit rough surface finishes. These rough areas may be
smoothed by a post-processing step, such as machining, ion milling,
solvent lapping, smearing with a hot surface, grinding, abrasion, and
vapor smoothing.
In the extruded thin-road wall approach and the extruded
bulk-road wall approach, caution must be taken to avoid collision of the
planarizer (e.g., the planarizer 20) with the pre-extruded layers (e.g., the
thin layers 106a-106d). Such collision can be avoided by timing the
planarizing of the jetted support material so that support material is
planarized only when it reaches a height along the z-axis that is greater
than that of the pre-extruded layers. Allowing modeling material of the
thin layers 106a-106d to cool sufficiently to support planarizing shear prior
to dispensing overlaying jetted supports will further protect reliability of the
object 100.
In the case of extruded thin layers 106a-106d, collision may
be avoided by interspersing the extrusion of the thin layers 106a-106d
with the jetting of the support structure layers 104a-104h in a systematic
fashion. First, one or more thin layers 106 may be extruded. Then,
support structure layers 104 are jetted up to at least the height of the
extruded thin layers 106. Planarizing is desirably not performed until the
support structure layers 104 reach or exceed the height of the extruded
thin layers 106. This prevents collisions between the planarizer with the
thin layers 106. Additionally, collision between the extrusion tip (e.g., the
extrusion tip 26) and support layers is prevented by planarizing the
support material before extrusion of subsequent thin layers 106.
Deposition of the thin layers 106, the support structure layers 104, and
planarizing is continued until the support structure increment i is

25
completed. The bulk layer 100s of modeling material may then be
deposited to fill the support structure increment;i.
Table 1 provides an example of a sequence for depositing
material to support the overhanging region 104 in the support structure
increment /', with reference to FIG. 8.
TABLE 1
Step Process Layer
1 Extrusion Thin layer 106a
2 Jetting Support structure layer 104a
3 Jetting Support structure layer 104b
4 Planarization Deposited support structure layers
5 Extrusion Thin layer 106b
6 Jetting Support structure layer 104c
7 Jetting Support structure layer 104d
8 Planarization Deposited support structure layers
9 Extrusion Thin layer 106c
10 Jetting Support structure layer 104e
11 Jetting Support structure layer 104f
12 Planarization Deposited support structure layers
13 Extrusion Thin layer 106d
14 Jetting Support structure layer 104g
15 Jetting Support structure layer 104h
16 Planarization Deposited support structure layers
17 Extrusion Bulk road 100d
As shown in Table 1 and FIG. 8, for each bulk layer (e.g.,
the bulk layer 100d), there are four thin layers 106 (i.e., M=A) and eight
support structure layers 114 (i.e., N=8). As such, following the extrusion

26
of each thin layer 106, N/M support layers 104 are jetted, where N/M is
two.
FIG. 9 depicts the chinking approach to support the
overhanging region 104. The chinking approach involves jetting layers
110 of a second modeling material into the areas under the overhanging
region 104 to form supporting walls. The second modeling material is
desirably not removable with the support structure 102 (e.g., not water
soluble), and desirably exhibits good adhesion to the extruded modeling
material. Jetting of the second modeling material may be performed
along with jetting of support material to build the corresponding
overhanging region 104. When subsequent bulk layers of modeling
material (not shown) are extruded to fill the support structure increment i,
the extruded modeling material fuses to the jetted second modeling
material, so that the jetted second modeling material forms a portion of
the object 100.
FIG. 10 depicts the lost wax approach to support the
overhanging region 104. The lost wax approach involves jetting layers
112 of an alternative material into the areas under the overhanging region
104 to form supporting walls. The alternative material is desirably
selected for to exhibit good melt properties (e.g., wax). When subsequent
bulk layers of modeling material (not shown) are extruded to fill the
support structure increment i, the heat of the modeling material melts the
alternative material, and displaces it. The lost wax approach and the
chinking approach may each be accomplished with a second jetting head,
with its own material supply.
FIG. 11 depicts the support stilts approach to support the
overhanging region 104. The support stilts approach involves jetting
support material to build stilts 114 as the support structure increment i is

27
formed. Modeling material is then extruded to fill the increment i, such
that the stilts 126 become embedded in the part 100. Where the stilts
114 join the region 104, the stilts 114 fan out to provide a contiguous
downward facing sidewall. After removal of the support structure 102 from
the completed object 100, pinholes or some embedded support material
will remain on the upward faces of the object 100.
The thermoplastic ploughing approach involves depositing
bulk roads of modeling material in areas that would be occupied by the
overhanging region 104, so that the modeling material fills its allotted
volume plus some of the volume that should be occupied by the support
structure 102. This can be done simultaneously with filling the support
structure increment i. A hot finger may then displace the modeling
material from the support structure region 104, and support material may
then be jetted into the resulting cavity.
Although the present invention has been described with
reference to preferred embodiments, workers skilled in the art will
recognize that changes may be made in form and detail without departing
from the spirit and scope of the invention.

28
CLAIMS:
1. A method for forming an object, the method comprising:
jetting a first material to form a plurality of layers that define
a support structure increment, the support structure
increment having an interior surface; and
extruding a second material to form a layer of the object,
wherein the layer of the object substantially conforms
to the interior surface of the support structure
increment.
2. The method of claim 1, and further comprising forming the
object in an environment maintained at a temperature ranging from about
a creep-relaxation temperature of the second material to about a glass
transition temperature of the second material.
3. The method of claim 1, and further comprising planarizing
the support structure increment.
4. The method of claim 1, wherein the layer of the object has a
thickness that is approximately equal to a thickness of the support
structure increment.
5. The method of claim 1, wherein the first material comprises
a solvent-dispersed material.
6. The method of claim 1, wherein the second material
comprises a thermoplastic material.
7. The method of claim 1, and further comprising sensing a
height of the support structure increment, wherein the number layers of
the plurality of layers of first material varies based on the sensed height.
8. The method of claim 1, and further comprising
compensating for a lack of support at an overhanging region of the
support structure increment, wherein the overhanging region is a region

29
of the support structure increment where the interior surface projects an
angle greater of at least about 30 degrees off vertical.
9. The method of claim 8, wherein the compensating
comprises extruding the second material to form a plurality of thin layers
to support the overhanging region, wherein each of the plurality of thin
layers has a thickness that is at most about half of a thickness of the layer
of the object.
10. The method of claim 8, wherein the compensating
comprises jetting a third material to form a plurality of thin layers to
support the overhanging region.
11. A method for forming an object, the method comprising:
providing a digital representation of the object, the digital
representation of the object comprising data that
represents an exterior surface of the object;
forming a digital representation of a support structure, the
digital representation of the support structure
comprising data that represents an interior surface of
the support structure, wherein the interior structure of
the support structure has a geometry defined by the
exterior surface of the object;
jetting a plurality of layers to form a support structure
increment based on the digital representation of the
support structure, wherein the support structure
increment includes a portion of the interior surface of
the support structure;
extruding a layer of the object based on the digital
representation of the object, wherein the layer of the

30
object substantially conforms to the interior surface of
the support structure increment; and
repeating the jetting and the extruding to form the object
and the support structure.
12. The method of claim 11, wherein the method further
comprises forming the object in an environment maintained at a
temperature ranging from about a creep-relaxation temperature of a
material of the layer of the object to about a glass transition temperature
of the material of the layer of the object.
13. The method of claim 11, and further comprising planarizing
the support structure increment.
14. The method of claim 14, wherein the layer of the object has
a thickness that is approximately equal to a thickness of the support
structure increment.
15. The method of claim 11, and further comprising:
cooling the object to substantially solidify the object; and
removing the support structure from the object by dissolving
at least a portion of the support structure in a solvent.
16. A system for forming an object, the system comprising:
a jetting head for jetting a first material to form layers of a
support structure, wherein the support structure has
an interior surface;
an extrusion head having an extrusion tip for extruding a
second material to form layers of the object, wherein
each of the layers of the object exhibit thicknesses
that are greater than thicknesses of each of the
layers of the support structure; and

31
a build chamber for maintaining a temperature that allows
the layers of the object to substantially conform to the
interior surface of the support structure.
17. The system of claim 16, and further comprising a planarizer
for planarizing the layers of the support structure.
18. The system of claim 16, and further comprising a sensor for
sensing a height of the layers of the support structure.
19. The system of claim 16, wherein the extrusion head further
comprises a second extrusion tip.
20. The system of claim 16, wherein the temperature ranges
from about a creep-relaxation temperature of the second material to a
glass transition temperature of the second material.

A method for forming an object, the method comprising
jetting a first material to form a plurality of layers (70) that define a support
structure increment (72), and extruding a second material to form a layer
(74) of the object (38). The layer (74) of the object (38) substantially
conforms to an interior surface (68) of the support structure increment
(72).

Documents:

02996-kolnp-2007-abstract.pdf

02996-kolnp-2007-claims.pdf

02996-kolnp-2007-correspondence others 1.1.pdf

02996-kolnp-2007-correspondence others.pdf

02996-kolnp-2007-description complete.pdf

02996-kolnp-2007-drawings.pdf

02996-kolnp-2007-form 1.pdf

02996-kolnp-2007-form 2.pdf

02996-kolnp-2007-form 3.pdf

02996-kolnp-2007-form 5.pdf

02996-kolnp-2007-international publication.pdf

02996-kolnp-2007-international search report.pdf

02996-kolnp-2007-pct request form.pdf

02996-kolnp-2007-priority document.pdf

2996-KOLNP-2007-(01-01-2014)-PETITION UNDER RULE 137.pdf

2996-KOLNP-2007-(02-11-2007)-FORM 13.pdf

2996-KOLNP-2007-(28-04-2014)-ASSIGNMENT.pdf

2996-KOLNP-2007-(28-04-2014)-CORRESPONDENCE.pdf

2996-KOLNP-2007-(28-04-2014)-PETITION UNDER RULE 137.pdf

2996-KOLNP-2007-(30-05-2014)-CORRESPONDENCE.pdf

2996-KOLNP-2007-(31-12-2013)-ABSTRACT.pdf

2996-KOLNP-2007-(31-12-2013)-CLAIMS.pdf

2996-KOLNP-2007-(31-12-2013)-CORRESPONDENCE.pdf

2996-KOLNP-2007-(31-12-2013)-FORM-3.pdf

2996-KOLNP-2007-(31-12-2013)-FORM-5.pdf

2996-KOLNP-2007-(31-12-2013)-OTHERS.pdf

2996-KOLNP-2007-ABSTRACT 1.1.pdf

2996-KOLNP-2007-CLAIMS 1.1.pdf

2996-KOLNP-2007-CORRESPONDENCE OTHERS 1.2.pdf

2996-KOLNP-2007-CORRESPONDENCE-1.3.pdf

2996-KOLNP-2007-FORM 26.pdf

2996-kolnp-2007-form-18.pdf

abstract-02996-kolnp-2007.jpg


Patent Number 266014
Indian Patent Application Number 2996/KOLNP/2007
PG Journal Number 14/2015
Publication Date 03-Apr-2015
Grant Date 27-Mar-2015
Date of Filing 16-Aug-2007
Name of Patentee STRATASYS, INC.
Applicant Address 14950 MARTIN DRIVE, EDEN PRAIRIE, MINNESOTA
Inventors:
# Inventor's Name Inventor's Address
1 ZINNIEL, ROBERT, L. C/O. STRATASYS, INC. 14950 MARTIN DRIVE, EDEN PRAIRIE, MINNESOTA 55344
2 BATCHELDER, JOHN, SAMUEL C/O. STRATASYS, INC. 14950 MARTIN DRIVE, EDEN PRAIRIE, MINNESOTA 55344
PCT International Classification Number G09G 5/02
PCT International Application Number PCT/US05/041274
PCT International Filing date 2005-11-15
PCT Conventions:
# PCT Application Number Date of Convention Priority Country
1 11/037,720 2005-01-18 U.S.A.